This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Improved Side Impact Protection: Design Optimisation for Minimum Harm
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published March 04, 2002 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
This paper describes a side impact crash simulation technique and optimisation process developed to select vehicle structural design, padding and airbag characteristics that provide the best protection for occupants of different size, gender and fragility in crashes of different type, direction and severity. This work is part of a collaborative research project between Australian car manufacturer Holden, Monash University Accident Research Centre and other partners with funding from a government research grant, to developed a design technique providing optimum protection to the Australian community involved in side impact crashes.
Multi-variable optimisation using a full vehicle side impact finite element model is not currently feasible as this approach would use an impractically high level of computer resources. Consequently, a unique and extremely efficient side impact crash simulation technique has been developed to support the design optimisation process. Created using MADYMO3D software, this simplified side impact model incorporates only those parts of the structure that influence components interacting with the occupant. Reduction in computational complexity was achieved by the partial de-coupling of the side impact event. A full vehicle finite element computer model, including test dummy was utilised to predict the structural response to side impact, and this response was used as input for the new, simplified optimisation model. The commercial optimisation package Isight was used to control the optimisation process. Validation was performed using data from vehicle side impact tests, side impact sled tests and full vehicle finite element computer model predictions.
Societal Harm1 has been used for the objective function. For each simulation, dummy injury responses were translated into injury risk via the use of Injury Assessment Functions, and then from injury risk into societal cost. During each iteration cycle, societal costs from simulations with different crash configurations and occupant types were weighted according to the crash frequency observed during field study, thereby giving the measure of total Harm for that given trial design. After iterating through the range of design variables, the best set of interior trim, restraint and structural parameters was selected to provide maximum community protection.
CitationNelson, D. and Sparke, L., "Improved Side Impact Protection: Design Optimisation for Minimum Harm," SAE Technical Paper 2002-01-0167, 2002, https://doi.org/10.4271/2002-01-0167.
SAE 2002 Transactions Journal of Passenger Cars - Electronic and Electrical Systems
Number: V111-7; Published: 2003-09-15
Number: V111-7; Published: 2003-09-15
- Sparke, L.J. Restraint System Optimisation for Minimum Societal Harm SAE Paper 98-S1-0-12 1998
- Fildes, B.N. Cameron, M. “Harm and Harm Estimates for Australia” Paper presented at the Monash University Short Course on the Biomechanics of Injury and Vehicle Crashworthiness February 1998
- Gibson, T.G. Fildes, B.G. Deery, H. Sparke, L.J. Benetatos, E. Fitzharris, M. McLean, J. Vulcan, P. “Improved Side Impact Protection: A Review of the Injury Patterns, Injury Tolerance and Dummy Measurement Capabilities” Monash University Accident Research Centre Melbourne, Australia 2001
- Fildes, B.N. Gabler, H.C. Fitzharris, M. Morrris, A.P. “Determining Side Impact Priorities Using Real-World Crash Data and Harm” Proceedings of IRCOBI 2000
- Sparke, L.J. “Front Structure Design for Minimum Societal Harm” Safety Conference Adelaide 1993
- Sparke, L J Hou, J “Restraint System Optimisation” Proceedings of the 39th Stapp Conference Society of Automotive Engineers Inc Warrendale, PA, USA 1995
- Sparke, L.J. “Head and Neck Injury in Side Impacts” The Proceedings of the 15th International Technical Conference on Enhanced Safety of Vehicles Paper No. 96-S8-O-01 Melbourne, Australia 1996
- “Social Cost of Transport Accidents in Australia” Report by the Bureau of Transport and Communications Economics Canberra, Australia 1998
- Steadman, L. Bryan, R.J. “Cost of Road Accidents in Australia” Occasional Paper 91, Bureau of Transport and Communications Economics Australian Government Printing Service Canberra 1988