EFFECTS OF SPEECH VERSUS TACTILE DRIVER SUPPORT MESSAGES ON DRIVING BEHAVIOUR AND WORKLOAD
Published June 04, 2001 by National Highway Traffic Safety Administration in United States
Annotation ability available
In a driving simulator experiment, effects were tested of an integrated support system on driving behaviour, user acceptance and workload. An alternative workload measure was used based upon peripheral vision. Two modes of support (tactile and speech messages) were compared to a control condition without support. Subjects were confronted with critical incidents dealing with lateral and longitudinal control on rural roads and motorways. The experiment showed that speech warnings are better suited for things related to law-enforcement, while tactile warnings are more suitable for situations directly related to driver safety. Although tactile warnings do result in compliance in enforcement type of situations, compliance is less than with speech warnings. For safety-related situations that do not require an immediate response, such as when approaching a sharp curve while speed is too high, speech warnings have the same effects as tactile warnings. However, if the criticality of the situation increases fast, for example when a lead vehicle brakes unexpectedly, tactile warnings result in more favourable effects than speech warnings. Still, both speech and tactile warnings do have a favourable effect of driver safety in a general way. The Peripheral Detection Task showed to be sensitive to variations in workload that were caused by different driving situations and to variations caused by short lasting increases in workload as a result of attending to the system messages.
CitationMartens, M. and van Winsum, W., "EFFECTS OF SPEECH VERSUS TACTILE DRIVER SUPPORT MESSAGES ON DRIVING BEHAVIOUR AND WORKLOAD," SAE Technical Paper 2001-06-0080, 2001.
- Bekiaris, E. & Portouli, E. (1999) Driver warning strategies, Internal deliverable ID4.1. IN-ARTE Project TR4014.
- De Vos, A.P., Godthelp, J., Theeuwes, J. & Verwey, W.B. (1996) The influence of a Heading Control system on driver workload (Report TM-96-C048). Soesterberg, The Netherlands: TNO Human Factors Research Institute.
- Hart, S.G. & Staveland, L.E. (1988) Development of NASA-TLX (Task Load Index): results of empirical and theoretical research. In: Hancock P.A. & Meshkati N. (eds.), Human Mental Workload (p. 139–183). Amsterdam: North Holland.
- Hoekstra, W., Van der Horst, A.R.A. & Kaptein, N.A. (1997) Visualisation of road design for assessing human factors aspects in a driving simulator. Proceedings Driving Simulator Conference (DSC ‘97), 8–9 September, Lyon, France.
- Hogema, J.H. & Hoekstra, W. (1998) Description of the TNO Driving Simulator (Report TM-98-D007). Soesterberg, The Netherlands: TNO Human Factors Research Institute.
- IN-ARTE (1998) Integration of navigation and anticollision for rural traffic environment, Annex 1 - Project programme, EU Telematics Applications Programme, sector Transport, project no TR4014, February 1998.
- Janssen, W.H. & Nilsson, L. (1990) An experimental evaluation of in-vehicle collision avoidance systems. Deliverable GIDS/MAN2, Drive Project V1041, Generic Intelligent Driver Support Systems. Groningen, The Netherlands: Traffic Research Centre.
- Martens, M.H. & van Winsum, W. (1999) Acceptability of activation criteria for a driver support system (Report TM-99-C054). Soeterberg, The Netherlands: TNO Human Factors Research Institute.
- Miura, T. (1986) Coping with situational demands: A study of eye movements and peripheral vision performance. In Gale, A.G. Brown, I.D. Haslegrave, C.M. Smith P. & Taylor S. (eds.), Proceedings of Vision in Vehicles, (p. 205–216). Amsterdam: Elsevier, North Holland.
- Rumar, K. (1990) The basic driver error: late detection. Ergonomics, 33, 1281–1290.
- Van der Laan, J.D. (1998) Acceptance of automatic violation-registration systems. PhD Thesis, University of Groningen.
- Verwey, W.B. & Veltman, J.A. (1995) Measuring workload peaks while driving. A comparison of nine common workload assessment techniques (Report TM-1995-B4). Soesterberg, The Netherlands: TNO Human Factors Research Institute.
- Verwey, W.B. (1996) Evaluating safety effects of in-vehicle information systems (IVIS). A field experiment with traffic congestion information systems (RDS-TMC) and preliminary guidelines for IVIS (Report TM-96-C068). Soesterberg, The Netherlands: TNO Human Factors Research Institute.
- Verwey, W.B., Brookhuis, K.A. & Janssen, W.H. (1996) Safety effects of in-vehicle information systems (Report TM-96-C002). Soesterberg, The Netherlands: TNO Human Factors Research Institute.
- Wickens, C.D. (1984) Processing resources in attention. In Parasuraman R. and Davies D.R. (Eds.) Varieties of attention. (pp. 63–102). London: Academic Press.
- Williams, L.J. (1985) Tunnel vision induced by a foveal load manipulation. Human Factors, 27, 221–227.
- Williams, L.J. (1995) Peripheral target recognition and visual field narrowing in aviators and nonaviators. The International Journal of Aviation Psychology, 5, 215–232.
- Zijlstra, F.R.H. & Van Doorn, L. (1985) The construction of a scale to measure perceived effort. Delft, The Netherlands: Department of Philosophy and Social Sciences, Delft University of Technology.