This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
DIFFICULTIES IN DETERMINING THE CAUSE OF REAL-WORLD CRASH INJURIES: A CASE STUDY OF A NASS INVESTIGATION
Technical Paper
2001-06-0065
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
This paper describes a National Automotive Sampling System (NASS) case in which a parked 1958 Chevrolet Bel Air was rear-ended by a 1991 Dodge Grand Caravan whose unbelted driver sustained fatal chest injuries despite the presence of an airbag. This particular case was chosen because different reviewers of the information from the crash investigation have proposed conflicting conclusions about the role of the airbag in the fatal injuries. The NASS investigators and others concluded that the driver bottomed out the airbag resulting in fatal chest injuries. Insurance Institute for Highway Safety researchers concluded that the driver either was out of position due to late firing of the airbag or was slumped over the wheel due to a high blood alcohol concentration; in either case they attributed the fatal injuries to airbag inflation forces. Thus, in one scenario the airbag had insufficient power, and in the others it had too much power.
Injury measures from a Hybrid III driver dummy seated in a Grand Caravan in a test re-creation of the real-world crash indicated low risk of serious injury to all body regions except the chest. The recorded chest compression was slightly higher than the injury reference value for a localized loading, but this measurement underestimated actual chest deflection because a postcrash inspection showed that off-axis loading had permanently deformed the ribs. During the crash test the airbag did not deploy late, but contact between the chest and steering wheel occurred because the steering column rotated upward. Separately, two static airbag deployment tests were conducted to determine the likelihood that the airbag could have caused the fatal chest injuries if the driver had been slumped over the wheel. Injury measures from these tests indicated a significant injury risk when the dummy was positioned close to the airbag module. The test results refute the hypothesis that the driver bottomed out the airbag; instead, either steering column movement or direct contact with the deploying airbag are the most likely cause of the fatal injuries.
Recommended Content
| Technical Paper | Real Time Control of Restraint Systems in Frontal Crashes |
| Technical Paper | Airbag Protected Crash Victims - The Challenge of Identifying Occult Injuries |
| Ground Vehicle Standard | Fixed Rigid Barrier Collision Tests |
Authors
Topic
Citation
Arbelaez, R. and O’Neill, B., "DIFFICULTIES IN DETERMINING THE CAUSE OF REAL-WORLD CRASH INJURIES: A CASE STUDY OF A NASS INVESTIGATION," SAE Technical Paper 2001-06-0065, 2001.Also In
References
- Consumers Union 1958 Consumer Reports 23 2 87 92
- Highway Loss Data Institute 2000
- Horsch, J. Lau, I. Andrzejak, D. Viano, D. Melvin, J. Pearson, J. Cok, D. Miller, G. 1990 Assessment of airbag deployment loads (SAE 902324 ) Proceedings of the 34th Stapp Car Crash Conference 267 88 Warrendale, PA Society of Automotive Engineers
- Melvin, J.W. Horsch, J.D. McCleary, J.D. Wideman, L.C. Jensen, J.L. Wolanin, M.J. 1993 Assessment of air bag deployment loads with the small female Hybrid III dummy (SAE 933119 ) Proceedings of the 37th Stapp Car Crash Conference 121 32 Warrendale, PA Society of Automotive Engineers
- Mertz, H.J. Horsch J.D. Horn, G. 1991 Hybrid III sternal deflection associated with thoracic injury severities of occupants restrained with force-limiting shoulder belts SAE Technical Paper Series 910812
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration 1991
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration 2001 Special Crash Investigation Program. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Transportation http://www.nhtsa.dot.gov/people/ncsa/sci.html
- Reed, M.P. Manary, M.A. Flannagan, C.A.C. Schneider, L.W. Arbelaez, R.A. 2001 Improved ATD positioning procedures SAE Technical Paper Series 2001-01-0118
- Schroeder, G. Eidam, J. 1997 Typical injuries caused by airbag in out-of-position situations – an experimental study Proceedings of the 1997 International IRCOBI Conference on the Biomechanics of Impact
- Viano, D.C. Lau, I.V. 1986 The viscous criterion – bases and applications of an Injury Severity Index for soft tissues SAE Technical Paper Series 861882
- Yoganandan, N. Pintar, F.A. Skrade, D. Chmiel, W. Reinartz, J.M. Sances, A., Jr. 1993 Thoracic biomechanics with air bag restraint (SAE 933121 ) Proceedings of the 37th Stapp Car Crash Conference 133 44 Warrendale, PA Society of Automotive Engineers
- Zuby, D.S. Cammisa, M.X. Ferguson, S.A. 2001 Analysis of driver fatalities in frontal crashes of airbag-equipped vehicles in 1990–98 NASS/CDS SAE Technical Paper Series 2001-01-0156
- Zuby, D.S. O’Neill, B 2001 Steering column movement in severe frontal crashes and its potential effect on airbag performance Proceedings of the 17th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (CD ROM) Washington, DC National Highway Traffic Safety Administration