This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Valve Seat Recession - An Independent Review of Existing Data
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published June 19, 2000 by SAE International in United States
This content contains downloadable datasetsAnnotation ability available
The mechanism of valve seat recession is well understood and a review of the existing literature shows that it consists of two processes - the generation of hard particles that then grind or abrade the valve seats. Metallic fuel additives can prevent recession by stopping the generation of these hard particles. Both new and previously published data are presented to demonstrate that low concentrations of all the commonly available additives provide adequate protection for most service applications. However, the data also show that severe testing with low treat rates will produce valve seat recession. The author argues that, if sufficient concentration of additive is used, the initiation of recession is stopped under extremely severe conditions and alternatives to lead can offer complete protection.
The paper concludes that the use of lead replacement additives should be at the maximum possible level commensurate with all aspects of engine performance. There are no standard tests for valve seat recession and, as a consequence, the additive supplier must be responsible for recommending dose rates that do not lead to potentially harmful side effects.
CitationHutcheson, R., "Valve Seat Recession - An Independent Review of Existing Data," SAE Technical Paper 2000-01-2015, 2000, https://doi.org/10.4271/2000-01-2015.
Data Sets - Support Documents
|[Unnamed Dataset 1]|
|[Unnamed Dataset 2]|
- Phasing out leaded gasoline - the way forward. Reading, Keith and McArragher, Steve; Shell International Petroleum Co. Ltd. SLBPC, London 1998 (Based on reference 9).
- Valve Problems with Lead Free Gasoline. Giles, William; Valve Div., TRW, Inc. SAE 710368.
- Some aspects of the problem of valve-seat wear with non-leaded gasolines. Barker, R.F.; Shell Research Ltd. Paper C291/73, I.Mech.E. First Euro Tribology Conference, London, 1973.
- The Effects of Low-Lead and Unleaded Fuels on Gasoline Engines. Weaver, Christopher S.; Radian Corp. SAE 860090.
- Car Maintenance Expense in Owner Service with Leaded and Non-Leaded Gasolines. Witteringham, J.S., Felt, A.E. et al. SAE 720499.
- Today's Gasoline Concerns - injector plugging and valve seat wear. Tupa, R.C.; Lubrizol Corporation. Paper AM-86-21 to NPRA meeting, Los Angeles, 1986.
- Effects of Using Unleaded and Low-Lead Gasoline and Gasoline Containing Non-Lead Additives on Agricultural Engines Designed for Leaded Gasoline., Garbak, John A. and Grinell, Gerald E. SAE 871622.
- Prevention of Valve-Seat Recession in European Markets. McArragher, J S (Shell International Petroleum Co Ltd), Clarke, L J and Paesler, H (Shell Research Ltd). Paper CEC/93/EF19 to the 4th CEC F&L Symposium, Birmingham, 1993.
- The phase-out of leaded gasoline in Europe: - Passenger car populations and future fuel requirements. Reading, K; Hickey C E, and Clarke-Sturman, A J; Shell International Petroleum Company. Institution of Mechanical Engineers Autotech '97 Conference, N.E.C., Birmingham, November 1997.
- UK road trials to evaluate valve seat protection additives. Openshaw, M. Ethyl Petroleum Additives, Bracknell, February 1999. (Previously unpublished)
- Potential high-temperature corrosion in automobiles running on lead-replacement gasoline. Stott, H; Corrosion and Protection Centre - UMIST. Retail Motor Industry Federation Seminar, London November 1998.
- A survey of European gasoline qualities - summer 1996. Döremer, W. et al. CONCAWE Report No. 5/98, Brussels, October 1998.
- Private communication. Ethyl R&D Center and Cameron Associates, April 1999.
- Effects of using unleaded and low-lead gasolines, and non-lead additives on agricultural engines designed for leaded gasolines. US Environmental Protection Agency and Department of Agriculture Joint Report. Washington D.C., April 1987.