This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
A Systems Engineering Approach to Engine Cooling Design
Technical Paper
1999-01-3780
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
This paper is divided into two parts:
- Part 1 - Systems engineering fundamentals
- Part 2 - Engine cooling design from a systems engineering perspective
In Part 1, we explain how the task of designing a complex system can be made easier by the application of Systems Engineering principles. (This part is self contained and may be of general interest to those who have no special interest in engine cooling).
Systems Engineering provides three key benefits:
- It facilitates communication:
- Requirements define the problem, they allow team members to see their own work in context
- Key information is standardized and made easier to visualize and verify.
- An “audit trail” is maintained ensuring that important information is documented, and human memory is no longer relied on for important decisions.
- Translates requirements into design.
- Ensures that all requirements are specified in common terms and none are missed
- Ensures that requirements are consistent and linked from the customer to the vehicle and all the way down to components.
- Ensures that manufacturing and service issues are addressed up-front in the design process.
- Defines the interactions between the OEM's and the Suppliers
In part 2, we examine cooling system design using System Engineering principles.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Theoretical Approach for Degassing Tank Design |
Technical Paper | IMPROVING ENGINE PARTS by DIRECT MEASUREMENT OF STRAIN |
Authors
Citation
Kanefsky, P., Nelson, V., and Ranger, M., "A Systems Engineering Approach to Engine Cooling Design," SAE Technical Paper 1999-01-3780, 1999, https://doi.org/10.4271/1999-01-3780.Also In
References
- International Council on Systems Engineering http://www.incose.org/
- Grady, Jeffrey O. System engineering planning and enterprise identity Boca Raton, FL CRC Press 1995
- IEEE 1220-1994 sect 3.1.50 IEEE Trial-Use Standard for Application and Management of the Systems Engineering Process
- Termaat, Keith B. Quick QFD Guidebook Ford MotorCompany 1995
- Hooks, Ivy Writing good requirements Fourth annual Symposium INCOSE http://www.complianceautomation.com/papers
- Hooks, Ivy Why Johnny can't write requirements AIAA conference 1990 http://www.complianceautomation.com/papers
- Kar, Pradip Bailey, Michelle Characteristics of good requirements 6th INCOSE Symposiums http://www.complianceautomation.com/papers
- Taguchi, Genichi Introduction to Quality Engineering 1986 Asian Productivity Organization
- Collier, John G. Thome, John R. Convective Boiling and Condensation 3 rd 1996 Oxford University Press
- Woods, L. E. Kabat, D. M. “Locating IC Engine Hot-Spots Using a Magnesium borate Solution” SAE- 741016
- Miller, D. S. Internal Flow Systems (1990) BHRA Reprinted by permission from BHRA (Information Services)
- Ford Motor Company Windtunnel test report SCF5919 1983
- Veling, T. R. Wiklund, G. C. Park, K. H. Engineering developments of elliptical tube mechanical assembly aluminum radiator SAE 860079
- King, W. Weltman, W.C. Performance of aluminium automotive radiators SAE Paper No. 790400
- Paquet, Andre Comparison of brazing processes for aluminum heat exchanger manufacturing SAE 931093
- Park, K.H. Barkley, J.M. Woody, J.R Vacuum brazing of aluminum radiators for Ford Tempo/Topaz SAE 860644
- Bolingbroke, R.K. Gray, A. Lauzon, D. Optimization of Nokolok ® brazing conditions for higher strength brazing sheet SAE 971861
- Le Gauyer, Philipe Jose, Garcia Alloy selection for headers of CAB brazed aluminum radiators SAE 971779
- Sunderberg, R. Tapper, T. Beal, R.E. Melnyk, W. Optimized brazed copper-brass radiators SAE 954036
- Webb, Ralph L. Principles of enhanced heat transfer Wiley-Interscience Pub. 1994
- Glober, Stefan Investigation of Ford Motor Company compact heat exchangers Brighton Polytechnic 1983
- Gardner, K. A. Efficiency of extended surfaces Trans. ASME 67 1945
- Davenport, C.J. Heat transfer and fluid flow in louvered triangular ducts Ph.D. Thesis Lanchester Polytechnic Coventry 1980
- Davenport, C.J. Correlations for heat transfer and flow friction characteristics of louvered fins AIChE 225 79 1983
- Achaichia, A. The performance of louvred tube-and-plate fin heat transfer surfaces Ph.D. Thesis Brighton Polytechnic 1987
- Webb, R.L. Yu-juei, Chang Chi-chuan, Wang Heat transfer and friction correlations for louver fin geometry SAE 954065
- Shah, Ramesh K. Compact heat exchangers Heat exchangers Thermal-hydraulic fundamentals and design Karaç, S. Bergels, A.E. Mayinger, F. McGraw-Hill 1981
- Kays, W. M. London, A.L. Compact heat exchangers Krieger 1998
- Bouzida, S. Mignot, C. Optimization of fin louver design based on CFD SAE 970832
- Achichia, A Cowell, T.A. Heat transfer and pressure drop characteristics of flat tube and louvered plate fin surfaces Expermental Thermal and Fluid Science 1 1988
- Cowell, T.A. Cross, D.A. Airside fouling of internal combustion engine radiators SAE 801012
- Jackson, A. Price, H.C.R. High performance core technology for brazed aluminum radiators SAE 954016
- Karaç, Sadik Liu, Hongtan Heat exchangers - selection rating and thermal design CRC Press 1998
- Petukhov, B.S. Heat transfer in turbulent pipe flow with variable physical properties Advances in Heat Transfer 6 Irving, T.F. Hartnell, J.P. Achedemic Press 1970
- Kern, Josef Eitel, Jochen State of the art and future developments of aluminum radiators for cars and trucks SAE 931092
- Magnusson, A. Mannerskog, B. Schölin, K. Sender, U. Waterside corrosion of brazed aluminum automotive radiators SAE 954034
- Schölin, Kent Mannerskog, Bo Corrosion resistant aluminum radiator materials for vacuum and controlled atmosphere brazing SAE 931077
- Jose, Garcia Randall, Shearer Internal corrosion testing of aluminum radiators SAE 931107
- Garcia, J.J. Twichell, D.J. Internal corrosion/erosion testing of welded aluminum radiator tubes for passenger cars and heavy duty trucks SAE 954033
- Stapleford, W.R. Factors affecting the selection of fans for automotive engine cooling applications International Conference on Fan design & Applications September 7 9 1982 BHRA Fluid Engineering
- Caltrider, J. L. Davis, F. V. Madhavan, R. Veling, T. R. Impact of computer aided engineering on Ford light truck cooling design and development processes SAE 931104
- Van Houten, R. Hickey, R. Kobayashi, S. Fan wake measurements by five-hole yaw tube and laser aneometer Airflow Research and Manufacturing Corporation (BoschGroup) Report 160 1993
- Shimada, K. Kuriwada, T. Sakai, T. Ohama, K. Design of aerodynamic diagonal flow fan for engine cooling SAE 980059
- Greenley, D.S. Stairs, R.W. Hickley, R.I. Rapid on-system cooling fan design & analysis using CFD and lifting surface theory C543/051/99: I.Mech.E.
- Coggiola, E. Dessale, B. Moreau, S. et. al. CFD based design for automotive engine cooling fans SAE 980427
- Eck, Bruno Fans - Design and operation of centrifugal, axial-flow and cross-flow fans Pergamon Press 1972
- Browland, F. Marcus, B. Sharpe, C. The influence of close-following upon the cooling module airflow SAE 981941
- Baxa, Donald E. Noise control in internal combustion engines John Wiley
- Brown, Neal A. The use of skewed blades for ship propellers and truck fans Journal of Sound and Vibration
- Pierce, Steven M. Shepherd, Mike Developement of modulating viscous fan drive for agricultural tractors SAE 821043
- Nelson, V. A. Robichaux, J. A Model to Simulate the Behavior of an Automotive Thermostat Vehicle Thermal Management Systems (VTMS 3) Conference Proceedings 1997
- Annual Book of ASTM Standards 15.05
- Marketing data supplied by Allied Signal 03 23 1999
- Prestone Physical Properties Data 1988 tenth
- Based in part on an after market survey by The Penray Companies, Inc. 06 1999
- Based on supplier input to Mary Ranger Ford Motor Co. 03 1999
- Majumdar, S. Tartaglia, J.M. Climax Research Services report S-7113 to Mary L. Ranger (Trace) May 27 1997
- Trace, M. (Ranger) Internal Ford Motor Co. report July 16 1997
- Turcotte, D.E. Olsen, A.W. Lockwood, F.E. Pfitzner, K.K. Meszaros, L.L. Cavitation Erosion-Corrosion Testing in Aluminum Pumps with Engine Coolant, Engine Coolants and Cooling Systems SAE SP-1456 March 1999
- International Standards Organization (ISO) The Magical Demystifying Tour of ISO 9000 and ISO14000 http://www.iso.ch/9000e/magical.htm
- Hooks, I. “Writing Good Requirements” Compliance Automation, Inc. 17629 El Camino Real, Suite 207, Houston, Texas 77058
- Grady, Jeffrey O. System engineering planning and enterprise identity Boca Raton, FL CRC Press 1995
- IEEE 1220-1994 sect 3.1.50 IEEE Trial-Use Standard for Application and Management of the Systems Engineering Process
- Fowlkes, William Y. Creveling, Clyde M. Engineering Methods for Robust Product Design Addison Wesley 1995
- Collier, John G. Thome, John R. Convective Boiling and Condensation Oxford University Press 1996
- Finlay, I.D. Boyle, R.J. Pirault, J.P. Biddulph, T. Nucleate and Film Boiling of Engine Coolants Flowing in a Uniformly Heated Duct of Small Cross Section SAE 870032
- Hetsroni, G. Handbook of Muliphase Systems - (chapter on two-phase flow instabilities) McGraw-Hill 1981
- Stelling, T. McAssey, E. V. Dougherty, T. Yang, B. W. The Onset of Flow Instability for Downward Flow in Vertical Channels Journal of Heat Transfer 118 3 August 1996
- Kays, W. M. London, A. L. Compact Heat Exchangers Kreiger Publishing 1996
- Webb, Ralph L. Principles of enhanced heat transfer Wiley-Interscience Pub. 1994
- Karaç, Sadik Liu, Hongtan Heat exchangers - selection rating and thermal design CRC Press 1998
- Church, A. H. Centrifugal Pumps and Blowers Wiley New York
- Stepanoff, A.J. Centrifugal and Axial Flow Pumps Krieger 1992
- Miller, D. S. Internal Flow Systems BHRA (Information Services)
- Nelson, V. A. Robichaux, J. A Model to Simulate the Behavior of an Automotive Thermostat Vehicle Thermal Management Systems (VTMS 3) Conference Proceedings 1997
- Wirtz, E. A. “Reservoir Design for Mobile Equipment Hydraulic Circuits” 1970 SAE 700722
- Hucho, Wolf-Heinrich Aerodynamics of Road Vehicles 4 SAE International
- Schlichting, H. Boundary-Layer Theory McGraw-Hill 1979
- Eck, Bruno Fans - Design and operation of centrifugal, axial-flow and cross-flow fans Pergamon Press 1972
- Wallis, R Allan Axial Flow Fans and Ducts Wiley 1983
- Bleier, Frank, P Fan Handbook McGraw-Hill 1997
- SAE Engine Coolant Testing 4 th SAE
- SAE Engine Coolants and Cooling Systems (SP-1456) 1999 SAE Warrendale, Pennsylvania
- ASTM 1999 Annual Book of ASTM Standards: Engine Coolants; Halogenated Organic Solvents and Fire Extinguishing Agents; Industrial Chemicals 1999 15.05 ASTM West Conshohocken, Pennsylvania
- Benyon, E. Cooper, N.R. Hannigan, H.J. Cooling System Corrosion in Relation to Design and Materials SAE 780919
- NACE International NACE International Basic Corrosion Home Study Course www.nace.org/naceframes/Education/eduindex.htm
- International Standards Organization (ISO) “The Magical Demystifying Tour of ISO 9000 and ISO 14000” www.iso.ch/9000e/magical.htm