This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
The Appropriate Use of “Delta-V” in Describing Accident Severity
Technical Paper
1999-01-1295
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
The term “Delta-V” has become widely used as a descriptor of accident severity for automotive crash investigations and safety research, and yet, the term remains poorly defined and vaguely used in too many situations. The literal definition of Delta-V is the velocity vector difference between a pre and post impact. Many current uses of “Delta-V” do not apply the appropriate qualifiers grounded in basic crash dynamic principles, and such lax use of the term can be misleading and, at times, erroneous. These problems are compounded when researchers refer in generic terms to “Delta-V” in national databases such as NASS without describing, or even knowing, what the physical basis for calculating the data entries were. The present analysis shows that essentially all the “Delta-V’s” in the NASS database are based on damage energy methods taken from vehicle damage forensic measurements. Examples of the use of Delta-V in the literature and in field accident reconstruction cases are discussed along with pointing out where errors can and do occur. Also presented is a timely review of basic physical principles of crash dynamics in the context of real-world crash modes and examples.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Essential Considerations in Delta-V Determination |
Technical Paper | Dynamic Analysis of ELR Retractor Spoolout |
Technical Paper | A Comprehensive Review of Pedestrian Impact Reconstruction |
Authors
Citation
Husted, D., Biss, D., and Heverly, D., "The Appropriate Use of “Delta-V” in Describing Accident Severity," SAE Technical Paper 1999-01-1295, 1999, https://doi.org/10.4271/1999-01-1295.Also In
References
- Stonex, K.A. The Single-Car Accident Problem SAE Paper No. 640799 , Society of Engineers, Inc., Automotive Engineering Congress and Exposition, Detroit, Michigan, January 13-17 1964 220 254
- Adolf, Egli, Stopping the Occupant of a Crashing Vehicles - A Fundamental Study SAE Paper No. 670038 , January 9-13 1967 259 289
- Martin, D.E., Kroell, C.K., Vehicle Crush and Occupant Behavior SAE Paper No. 670034 , Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc., Automotive Engineering Conference, Detroit, January 9-13 1967 1 42
- Emori, R.I. Analytical Approach to Automobile Collisions SAE Paper No. 680016 , Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc.Automotive Engineering Congress, Detroit, Michigan, January 8-12 1968 1 9
- Mackay, G.M. Injury and Collision Severity, SAE Paper No. 680779 , Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc., 1968 207 219
- McHenry R.R. Miller, P.M. State-of-the-Art-Automo-bile Structural Crashworthiness, SAE Paper No. 700412 , Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc., February 1970 913 926
- Frampton, R.J., Mackay, G.M., Parkin, S., SAE Paper No. 700175 , Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc.,Automotive Engineering Congress, 1970 Detroit, Michigan, 1 5 12-16 January
- Langwieder, K. Passenger Injuries in Collisions and Their Relation to General Speed Scale, SAE Paper No. 730963 17th Stapp Car Crash Conference November 1993 1 34
- Campbell, K.L. Energy Basis for Collision Severity, SAE Paper No. 740565 , Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc., 1974 1 13
- Marquardt, J.F. Vehicle and Occupant Factors that Determine Occupant Injury, SAE Paper No. 740303 , Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc., Automotive Engineering Congress, Detroit, Michigan, February 25 March 1 1974
- Struble, D., Ph.D., Petersen, R., Wilcox, B., Friedman, D., Societal Costs, and Their Reduction by Safety Systems, Proceedings, Fourth International Congress on Automotive Safety U.S. Department of Transportation 14-16 July 1975 695 712
- Ventre, P. Proposal for Test Evaluation of Compatibility Between very Different Passenger Cars, Section Two: The French Technical Presentation Part 3, Report on the Fourth International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles, U.S. Department of Transportation-National Highway Traffic Safety Administration Kyoto, Japan, 13-16 March 1973 201 209
- Sato, T. Effects of Seat Belt and Related Injuries, Proceedings of the 10th Congress of the International Association for Accident and Traffic Medicine May 27-31 1985 Tokyo, Japan
- Friedman, K. Klimko, L.A. Evaluating the Crashworthiness of Small Cars Using Accident Data Eighth International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles Section 5: Technical Sessions, U.S. Department of Transportation-National Highway Traffic Safety Administration Wolfsburg, Germany 1980 787 797
- Nilsson-Ehle, A. Gustafsson, H.N.C. Evaluation of a Method for Determining the Velocity Change in Traffic Accidents, Ninth International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles Section: 5 Technical Sections, U.S. Department of Transportation-National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Kyoto, Japan 1982 741 750
- Newland, C. Scheffel, G. Armstrong, M. A Scientific Method for Analysing Vehicle Safety, Paper Number 98-S11-O-05, ESV, Australia 1998
- Personal Communication with Seymore Stern of the NHTSA.
- Transportation Data Center, Data Set Codebook, The University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute October 1990
- NASS CDS 1989 Version Jan 1491, Number 91-9, Transportation Data Center, Data Set Codebook, The University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute, July 1991
- NASS CDS 1990 Version Aug 0591, Number 92-3, Transportation Data Center, Data Set Codebook, The University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute, January 1992.
- NASS CDS 1991 Version Aug 1892, Number 92-13, Transportation Data Center, Data Set Codebook, The University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute, December 1992.
- NASS CDS 1992 Nov Number 94-1 Transportation Data Center, Data Set Codebook, The University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute January 1994.
- NASS CDS 1993 Version Nov 1197, Number 98-3, Transportation Data Center, Data Set Codebook, The University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute April 1998
- NASS CDS 1994, Version Nov 0497, Number 98-4, Transportation Data Center, Data Set Codebook, The University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute April 1998
- NASS CDS 1995 Version Feb 2197, Number 97-1, Transportation Data Center, Data Set Codebook, The University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute March 1997.
- NASS CDS 1996, Version Sep 1197, Number 97-6, Transportation Data Center, Data Set Codebook, The University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute, October 1997.
- Kent, R.W. Strother, C.E. Wooden Pole Fracture Energy in Vehicle Impacts SAE Paper No. 980214 , Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc., February 1998
- Roberts, V.L. Compton, C.P. The Relationship Between Delta V and Injury, SAE Paper No. 933111 , Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. November 1993
- National Automotive Sampling System/Crashworthiness Data System, 1992-1994 U. S. Department of Transportation, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, DOT HS 808 38, April 1997.
- Lewis, P.R. Moiz, F.J. IV Schmidtke, S.Z. Bidez, M.W. A NASS-Based Investigation of Pelvic Injury within the Motor Vehicle Crash Environment, SAE Paper No. 962419 , Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc., November 1996 1 17
- King, A.I., Yang., K.H. Research in Biomechanics of Occupant Protection, The Journal of Trauma Injury, Infection, and Critical Care, 38 4, April 1995 570 576
- Evans, L. Safety-Belt Effectiveness: The Influence of Crash Severity and Selective Recruitment, Accident Analysis and Prevention, Official Journal of: Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine, 28 4, Great Britain July 1996 423 433
- Cunningham v. Mitsubishi Motors Corp., Civil Action No. C-3-88-582. (S.D. Ohio)
- Meyer v. Mazda Motors Corp., Cause No. 685669, Cir. Ct. of St. Louis County, Missouri
- Chew v. Volkswagen of America, Inc., No. 293577, Superior Ct. of Contra Costa County, CA
- Walker G.W. Young, B.,O., Warner, C.Y., Crash Tests of an Articulated Energy-Absorbing Gore Barrier, Employing Light Weight Concrete Cartridges, Highway Research Record 386 1972, 19 27
- Warner, C.Y., Free, J.C., Water Plastic Crash Attenuation System, Test Performance and Model Prediction Highway Research Record No. 343, 1971 83 92
- Malliaris, A.C. Hitchcock, R. Hedlund, J. A Search for Priorities in Crash Protection, SAE Paper No. 820242 , Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc., International Congress & Exposition, Detroit, Michigan, February 22-26 1982
- Kamal, M.M. Analysis and Simulation of Vehicle to Barrier Impact, SAE Paper No. 700414 , Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc., February 1970
- Horsch, J.D. Evaluation of Occupant Protection from Responses Measured in Laboratory Tests, SAE Paper No. 870222 , Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc., 1987, 13 42
- National Accident Sampling System, 1996 Crashworthiness Data System” Data Collection, Coding, and Editing Manual U.S. Department of Transportation National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, National Center for Statistics and Analysis, Washington, D.C. January 1996.
- Stucki, S.L. Fessahaie, O. Comparison of Measured Velocity Change in Frontal Crash Tests to NASS Computed Velocity Change, SAE Paper No. 980649 , Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc., February 1988 93 100
- O’Neill, B., Preuss, C.A., Nolan J.M., Relationships Between Computed Delta V and Impact Speeds for Offset Crash Tests Paper Number 96-S9-0-11 Australia 1996 1 8
- O’Neill, B. Lund, A.K. Zuby, D.S.. Preuss, C.A. Offset Frontal Impacts - A Comparison of Real-World Crashes with Laboratory Tests, The Fourteenth International Technical Conference on Enhanced Safety of Vehicles, Proceedings Volume 1, 94-S4-O-19, U.S. Department of Transportation-National Highway Traffic Safety Administration Munich, Germany, May 23-26 1994 649 663
- Hill, J.R. Frampton, R.J. MacKay, M. Appropriate Frontal Barrier Tests for Belted Occupants,” Accident Analysis and Prevention 27 6 1995 807 817