This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
An Analysis of 72 Real World Impacts - An Initial Investigationinto Injury and Complaint Factors
Technical Paper
1999-01-0640
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
An initial study into actual car to car collisions has been performed. The study provides insights into the factors associated with physical complaints in real collisions and identifies those areas requiring greater detail.
Data compiled from seventy-two, real world, rear automobile collisions shows that a gap exists between current testing and modeling and the realities of a typical rear impact. Analysis of the data indicates that among the most significant factors associated with physical complaints, in a rear impact, is an occupant’s reported awareness of the impending collision. Awareness of an imminent impact allows an occupant in a struck vehicle to exercise sufficient muscle control to prevent flexion/ extension injuries, of the neck, in many collisions. Other factors identified include gender, occupant position, preexisting injuries, seat belt usage, seat back failure and impact orientation. Finally, the data in the study reveals that the potential for significant head and brain injuries exists in pickups, and even large trucks, struck from the rear.
Analysis of the data suggests areas that may benefit from more detailed analysis. Among these are the specifics of the injuries/complaints, locations of previous injuries and occupant position.
Another contributing factor in preventing flexion/extension injuries of the neck is seat back failure. In those cases where the seat back failed, even slightly, flexion and hyperextension complaints in the neck tended to be less severe. This was found to be true even if the impact was a surprise and at high velocity. The potential may exist to modify current seat design to provide for energy absorption, thereby reducing flexion/extension injuries of the neck.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Smith, J., "An Analysis of 72 Real World Impacts - An Initial Investigationinto Injury and Complaint Factors," SAE Technical Paper 1999-01-0640, 1999, https://doi.org/10.4271/1999-01-0640.Also In
References
- Emori Horiguchi, Whiplash in Low Speed Vehicle Collisions SAE Paper Number 900052
- NTSB Safety Study (SS) 88/03 Performance of Lap/Shoulder Belts in 167 Motor Vehicle Crashes 1988
- Warner, Strother, James, Perl, Decker Occupant Protection in Rear End Collisions: I. Safety Priorities and Seat Belt Effectiveness SAE Paper Number 912913
- Navin, Romilly, An Investigation into Vehicle and Occupant Response Subjected to Low Speed Rear Impacts Proceedings of the Multidisciplinary Road Safety Conference VI June 1989
- McConnell, Howard, Guzman, Bomar, Raddin, Benedict, Smith, Hatsell, Analysis of Human Test Subjects Kinematic Responses to Low Velocity Rear End Impacts SAE Paper Number 1993
- Thompson, Romilly, Navin, Macnabb, Energy Attenuation Within the Vehicle During Low Velocity Rear End Impacts Report to Transport Canada
- Mertz, Patrick, Investigation of the Kinematics of Whiplash SAE Paper 670919
- Smiley, Cram, Margoles, Romano, Stiller, Innovations in Soft-Tissue Jurisprudence Trial Diplomacy Journal 15 5 Sept/Oct 1992
- Lyons, Brady Brady Simms, An investigation of Damage to the Human Temporomandibular Joint During Cranial Accelerations 41st Annual Proceedings, Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine 1997
- Barnsley, Fracp, Lord Bogduk, The Pathophysilogy of Whiplash Spine: State of the Art Reviews 7 3 September 1993
- Dalmotoas, Mechanisms of Injury to Vehicle Occupants Restrained by Three-Point Seat Belts SAE Paper 801311
- Otte, Sudkamp, Variations of Injury Patterns of Seat-Belt Users SAE Paper 870226
- Sturzenegger, DiStefano, Radanov, Radanov, Presenting Symptoms and Signs After Whiplash Injury: The influence of accident mechanisms Neurology April 1994
- Larder, Twiss Mackay, Neck Injury to Car Occupants Using Seat Belts Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine 1985
- Laberge, Nadeau, Tao, Maag, Neck Injuries Amongst Motor Vehicle Occupants involved in Collision Centre for Research on Transportation Montreal Canada 1993
- Hill, J.R. Mackay, G.M. Morris, A.P. Chest and Abdominal Injuries Caused by Seat Belt Loading 36 TH Annual Proceeding of AAAM 1992
- Blower, Campbell, Comparison of Occupant Restraints Based on Injury-Producing Contact Rates SAE Paper 942219
- Szabo, Welcher, Human Occupant Kinematic Response to Low-Speed Rear End Impacts SAE Paper 940532
- Matsushita, X-Ray Study of the Human Neck Motion Due to Head Inertia Loading SAE Paper 942208
- Bylund, Bjornstig, Sick Leave and Disability Pension Among Passenger Car Occupants Injured in Urban Traffic 41st Annual Proceedings, Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine 1997
- Traffic Accident Reconstruction The Traffic Institute Northwestern University
- Barzelay Lacy, Scientific Automobile Accident Reconstruction Matthew Bender Times Mirror Books 1964-1996
- Ommaya, Fisch, Mahone, Corrao, Letcher, Comparative Tolerances for Cerebral Concussion by Head Impact and Whiplash Injury in Primates SAE Paper 700401
- Thibault, Gennarelli, Bomechanics of Diffuse Brain Injuries SAE Paper 856022