This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Crush Energy and Structural Characterization
Technical Paper
1999-01-0099
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
A key aspect of accident reconstruction is the calculation of how much kinetic energy is dissipated as crush. By far the most widely used methods are derivatives of Campbell’s work, in which a linear relationship between residual crush and closing speed is shown to imply an underlying linearity between force and crush. “Consant-stiffness model” is the term used for such a representation of structural behavior.
Difficulties arise, however, when significant non-uniformities are present in the crush pattern (as in narrow-object and/or side impacts, for example). The term “residual crush” becomes more ambiguous. Do we mean maximum crush, area-weighted average crush, or some other measure of residual deformation? And is it sufficient to represent the non-uniform crush pattern by a single parameter?
Such considerations led to a re-development of the fundamental structural models, with an eye to determining whether the classical constant-stiffness model is the most appropriate. For narrow-object side impacts, a constant-force model was developed. For wide-object impacts, constant-stiffness and constant-force models were developed, along with a three-parameter model.
These models were applied to published side impact and narrow-object data. The constant-force model emerged as the preferred formulation for narrow-object side impacts, and was at least on a par with the constant-stiffness model for wide-object side impacts. For frontal impacts, wide-object test data could not predict narrow-object behavior with acceptable results.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Welsh, K. and Struble, D., "Crush Energy and Structural Characterization," SAE Technical Paper 1999-01-0099, 1999, https://doi.org/10.4271/1999-01-0099.Also In
References
- Energy as a Basis for Accident Severity -A Preliminary Study Campbell KL Doctoral Thesis University of Wisconsin, Department of Mechanical Engineering Madison, Wisconsin 1972
- Energy Basis for Collision Severity, Campbell KL Society of Automotive Engineers Paper 740565 3rd International SAE Conference on Occupant Protection, July 1974
- Research Safety Vehicle, Phase II II Comprehensive Technical Results, DiNapoli N Fitzpatrick M Strother C Struble D Tanner R Minicars, Inc. November 1977
- Test Report, Car-To-Pole Side Impact of a 1976 Volkswagen Rabbit Into a Breakaway Pole at 30.4 Mph, Ensco, Inc.
- Laboratory Procedures to Determine the Breakaway Behavior of Luminaire Supports in Mini-Sized Vehicle Collisions: Low Speed Forty-Five Degree Impact of a Mini-compact Sedan and a Validated Surrogate Breakaway Luminaire Support - Test Results Report - Test Number 1469-5A82 Howerter ED Hinch JA Owings RP 28 June 1982
- Side-Impact Aggressiveness Attributes - Car-To-Pole Side Impact Test of a 45 Crabbed Moving 1981 Volkswagen Rabbit Into a Fixed Rigid Pole at 20.1 Mph Bell L. NHTSA September 1984
- Side-Impact Aggressiveness Attributes - Car-To-Pole Side Impact Test of a 45 Crabbed Moving 1981 Volkswagen Rabbit Into a Fixed Rigid Pole at 19.95 Mph Bell L. NHTSA August 1984
- Side-Impact Aggressiveness Attributes - Car-To-Pole Side Impact Test of a 45 Crabbed Moving 1977 Volkswagen Rabbit Into a Fixed Rigid Pole at 25.0 Mph Bell L. NHTSA September 1984
- Laboratory Procedures to Determine the Breakaway Behavior of Luminaire Supports in Mini-Sized Vehicle Collisions: Thirty Mph Broadside Impact of a Honda Civic and a Breakaway Luminaire Support - Test Results Report - Test Number 1469-SI#4-85 Hinch JA Ensco, Inc. February 1986
- Laboratory Procedures to Determine the Breakaway Behavior of Luminaire Supports in Mini-Sized Vehicle Collisions: Side Impact - Rigid Pole Test Results Report - Test No’s SI#1, SI#2, SI#3, and SI#8 Hinch, JA Manhard G Owings RP Ensco, Inc. February 1986 DOT 907, 908, 909, and 911
- Title 49, Code of Federal Regulations, Part 571, Section 214
- A Summary of Recent Side Impact Research Conducted by the Federal Highway Administration Hargrave MW Hansen AG Hinch JA SAE Paper 890377 February 1989
- Energy Absorbed by Vehicle Structures in Side-Impacts Prasad AK SAE Paper 910599 1991
- Frontal Crush Energy and Impulse Analysis of Narrow Object Impacts Smith GC James MB Perl TR Struble DE The American Society of Mechanical Engineers Winter Annual Meeting December 1987
- A Repeated-Crash Test Technique for Assessment of Structural Impact Behavior Warner CY Allsop DL Germane GJ SAE Paper 860208 1986
- Crash III Model Improvements: Derivation of New Side Stiffness Parameters from Crash Tests 2 DT Willke, and MW Monk, DOT HS No. 807 353, June 1987