This content is not included in your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
The High Mounted Brake Lamp - The 4% Solution
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Published March 01, 1999 by SAE International in United States
Annotation ability available
The paper reviews some of the underpinnings of the research that was done that led to adoption of the high mounted brake lamp. The expected reduction in rearend collisions of 50%, attributable to the lamp, has not been realized. Most recently, a reduction of 4% was reported. This large difference between the predicted effectiveness of the safety device with its actual effect is disturbing. The paper attempts to show the reasons for the low effectiveness which include a lack of evidence for the high-mounting location, overriding an SAE standard on the intensity of high-mounted rear signal lamps and no valid theory of driver performance.
CitationMortimer, R., "The High Mounted Brake Lamp - The 4% Solution," SAE Technical Paper 1999-01-0089, 1999, https://doi.org/10.4271/1999-01-0089.
- Malone, T.B., Kirkpatrick, M., Kohl, K.S. and Baker, C. (1978). Field test evaluation of rear lighting systems. US-DOT report HS-803-467.
- Rausch, A., Wong, J. , &KirkpatrickM. (1982). A field test of two single center, high-mounted brake light systems. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 14, 287-292.
- Reilly, R.E., Kurke,D.S. and Buckenmaier, C.C. (1980). Validation of the reduction of rear end collisions by a high mounted auxiliary stoplamp. US-DOT report HS-805-360.
- Voevodsky,J., (1974). Rear-end collisions reduced: A large-scale experiment under natural conditions. SAE report 740614.
- Digges, K.H., Nicholson, R.M. and Rouse, E.J. (1985). The technical basis for the center high mounted stoplamp. SAE Report 851240.
- Mortimer. R. G., (1970). Automobile rear lighting and signaling research. Contract FH-11-6936, Univ. of Michigan report HuF-5.
- Crosley, J.,and Allen, M.J. (1966). Automobile brake light effectiveness: An evaluation of high placement and accelerator switching. American Journal of Optometry and Archives of American Academy of Optometry, May, 299-305.
- Schmidt-Clausen, H.J., (1977). Improvement of the rear signal system on motor vehicles by additional high mounted brake lamps. Automobil Technische Zeitschrift, 79, 1-4.
- Sivak, M., Post, D., Olson, P.L. & Donohue, R.J. (1981). Driver responses to high-mounted brake lights in actual traffic. Human Factors, 23, 231-235.
- Mortimer R.G., (1981). Field test evaluation of rear lighting deceleration signals. US-DOT report HS-806-125.
- Sivak, M., Post, D., Olson, P.L. & Donohue, R.J., (1981a). Automobile rear lights: Effects of the number, mounting height and lateral position on reaction times of following drivers. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 52, 795-802.
- Liger, M., Cavallo V.& Peruch, P., (1991). Comparison of different brake light systems. Proceedings, Vision in Vehicles-III, 351-358.
- Allen Corporation (1978). Field validation of taillights-report on phase 1: pilot testing. US-DOT HS-701-756.
- NPSRI. (1989) The effect of center high mounted stop lamps on vans and trucks. National Public Services Research Institute, Report DOT HS-807-506.
- Sivak, M., Conn, L.S. and Olson, P.L., (1986). Driver eye fixations and the optimal locations for automobile brake lights. Journal of Safety Research, 17, 13-22.
- Kahane, C.J., (1987). The effectiveness of center high mounted stop lamps: a preliminary evaluation. US-DOT report HS-807-076.
- Kahane, C.J., (1989). An evaluation of center high mounted stop lamps based on 1987 data. US-DOT report HS-807-442.
- Herman, R and Gardels, K, (1963). Vehicular Traffic Flow. Scientific American, 209, #6, 3-11.
- Rockwell, T.H. and Banasik, (1968). Experimental highway testing of alternative vehicle rear lighting systems. Final Report, US-DOT FH-11-6552, Systems Research Group, Ohio State University.
- Hoffman. E.R., (1968) Detection of velocity changes in car-following. Fourth Conference, Australian Road Research Board.
- Mortimer, R.G., (1990. Perceptual factors in rear-end crashes. Proceedings, Human Factors Society, 591-594.
- Mortimer, R. G. (1971). Car and truck rear lighting and signaling: the application of research findings. Proceedings, Symposium on Psychological Aspects of Driver Behavior, Noordwijkerhout, Netherlands, II.1.B. 1-16.
- Theeuwes J., (1991). Center high-mounted stop light: An evaluation.TNO Institute for Perception, Report IZF-1991-C-3.
- SAE J186. (1982) Supplemental high mounted stop and rear turn signal lamps for use on vehicles less than 2032 mm overall width. Society of Automotive Engineers.
- Farmer, C.M. (1996). Effectiveness estimates for center high mounted stop lamps: A six year study. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 28, 201-208.
- Kahane, C.J. and Hertz, E. (1998). The Long Term Effectiveness of Center High Mounted Stop Lamps in Passenger cars and Light Trucks. US-DOT report HS-808-696.
- Mortimer, R.G., (1984).The high mounted brake light federal standard: Examination of the basis for the requirement. SAE International Congress.
- Hoffmann,E and Mortimer,R.G. , (1996). Scaling of relative velocity between vehicles. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 28, #4, 415-421.
- Mortimer, R.G. (1986). In the high-mounted brakelight standard why is the brakelight high mounted? Accident Analysis and Prevention, 18, 71-72.
- Mortimer, R.G. (1976). Motor vehicle exterior lighting. Human Factors, 18, #3, 259-272.
- Fancher, P. and Bareket Z., (1998). An evolving model for studying driver/vehicle system performance in the longitudinal control of headway. Transportation Research Board, 77th annual meeting, Washington, DC.
- Seller, P., Song, B. and Hedrick, K.J. (1998). Development of a collision avoidance system. Automotive Engineering, September, 24-28.