This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Vehicle Structural Design Utilizing Optimized Finite Element Modeling
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
A study of an existing B-pillar was conducted to examine the changes required to increase the lateral load carrying capability by a factor of ten. A finite element optimization package was used to adjust the geometric and material characteristics simultaneously while minimizing weight. The results show that the weight and cost necessary for the ten-fold improvement in lateral load carrying capability were very low. Further, the results illustrate how structural design optimization with finite element modeling can be effectively utilized to create cost effective elements for use in an integrated occupant protection system.
Recommended Content
Authors
Citation
Friedman, K. and Mobrem, M., "Vehicle Structural Design Utilizing Optimized Finite Element Modeling," SAE Technical Paper 981013, 1998, https://doi.org/10.4271/981013.Also In
References
- Structural Research & Analysis Corporation COSMOS/M Santa Monica, CA
- Huang, Y. “Finite Element Method - Structure Analysis by Simulation” SAE 730446
- Kirioka, K. “Analysis of Body Structures” SAE 650026
- Thompson, J.E. “Vehicle Crush Prediction Using Finite-Element Techniques” SAE 730157
- Park, S.W. DuVall, F.W. “Finite Element Structural Analysis is Applied to an Automotive Door Structure” SAE 740320
- Nagy, L.I. “Static Analysis Via Substructuring of an Experimental Vehicle Front-End Body Structure” SAE 740323
- Chang, D.C. “Effects of Flexible Connections on Body Structural Response” SAE 740041
- Kajio, Y. Hagiwara, I. “Nonlinear Analysis of Car Body Structure” SAE 760022
- Kirioka, K. Hotta, Y. Saji, H. “Elasto-Plastic Analysis of Automobile Body Structure by the Finite Element Method” SAE 740039
- Ridha, R.A. “Finite Element Stress Analysis of Automotive Wheels” SAE 760085
- Tang, S.C. “Elasto-Plastic and Large Deflection Analysis of Thin Shells by the Flow Theory of Plasticity” SAE 770590
- Kowalski, M.F. Katnik, R.B. “A Substructuring Approach to Localized Plasticity Analysis,” SAE 770602
- Citipitioglu, E. Nicolas, V.T. Tolani, S.K. “Finite Element Method in Stress Analysis Practice” SAE 770605
- Parekh, C.J. Basas, J.E. Kothawala, K.S. “Application of Isoparametric Finite Elements in Vehicle Structural Mechanics” SAE 770606
- Katoh, H. Tahara, H. “Pre-processor for Finite Element Analysis and Its Application to Body Structure” SAE 780363
- Kirioka, K. Shitasaw, K. et al. “Application of Finite Element Method to Automobile Safety Evaluation” 17 th FISITA Congress 1978 Budapest, Hungary
- Egert, J. Sarkozi, L. “Strength Analysis of Bus-Siderframe by Finite Element Method Using Bar and Plane Elements” 17 th FISITA Congress 1978 Budapest, Hungary
- Calderale, P. Carro, A. Logenzi, C. “Car Accident Mathematical Model: Femur and Pelvis Stress Analysis of a Passenger Car” SAE 790990
- Kecman, D. Miles, J. “Application of Finite Element Method to the Door Intrusion and Roof Crush Analysis of a Passenger Car” SAE 790990
- Osborn, J. Thiel, L. “Optimal Design of Minimum Weight Structures” SAE 810686
- Hasselgren, A. Svanberg, K. “Beam models as tools for light weight design of car bodies using Finite Element Methods” 19 th FISITA Congress 1982 Melbourne, Australia
- Hunckler, C.J. Purdy, R.J. Austin, R.D. “Nonlinear Analysis of the Terex Scraper Rollover Protective Cab” SAE 850788
- Igarashi, M. Atsumi, M. “An Analysis of 3 pt Belted Occupant Impact Dynamics in Frontal Collision and Its Application” SAE 850436
- Winter, R. Courzet-Pascal, J. Pifko, A.B. “Front Crash Analysis of a Steel Frame Auto Using a Finite Element Computer Code” SAE 840728
- Yamaoka, H. Sakai, H. Ariyoshi, T. Fujii, M. “Computer Simulation of Automotive Body Crash Response” SAE 851685
- Kecman, D. Tidbury, G.H. Theoretical Prediction of the Complete Collapse Behaviour of a Coach Subject to the Proposed Full Scale Rollover Test 19 th FISITA Congress 1982 Melbourne, Australia
- Austin, D. Moore, G.G. Finite Element Modeling of Vehicle Bodies Using Substructuring Methods, Vehicle Structures I Mech E Conf. 1984-7
- Amos, R.J. Structural Design Analysis of Commercial Vehicle Cabs, Vehicle Noise and Vibration I Mech E Conf. 1984-5
- Packwood, J. Aurora, B. Application of the Finite Element Method to the Design of the Front Door of a Light Commercial Vehicle 20 th FISITA Congress 1984 Vienna, Austria
- Kecman, D. Tidbury, G. “Optimization of a Bus Superstructure from the Rollover Safety Point of View,” 10 th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles 1985 Oxford, England
- Suthurst, G. Ng. P. Sadeghi, M. “Inclusion of Crashworthiness in Concept Design” 10 th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles 1985 Oxford, England
- Brashce, R. Giazitzis, G. Schmitt, H. “Collapse Behavior Development of Body Components” 10 th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles 1985 Oxford, England
- Johnson, D. “Finite Element Design Optimization of the WABCO 170 ton Haulpak Truck Frame” SAE 860748
- Dirscmid, W. “Structural Modification for the Automated Design Process” SAE 860806
- Hardy, R. “Towards Optimised Side Impact Vehicle Structures” 11 th International Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles 1987 Washington, D.C.
- Grew, N. Beecroft, G. “Designing a Passive Restraint System” 11 th International Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles 1987 Washington, D.C.
- Kamal, M. “The Birth of the Spaceframe at General Motors 22 nd FISITA Congress” 1988 Dearborn, MI, USA
- Scharnhorst, T. “FEM CRASH - A Supercomputer Application” SAE 880897
- Steyer, C. Mack, P. et al “Mathematical Modelisation of Side Collisions” 12 th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles 1989 Goetborg, Sweden
- Sakuria, T. Aoki, T. “On the Safety Body Structure of Finite Element Method Analysis” 12 th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles 1989 Goetborg, Sweden
- Kurimoto, K Taga, K. et al “Simulation of Vehicle Crashworthiness and Its Application” 12 th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles 1989 Goetborg, Sweden
- Seeds, A. Nardini, D. Cassessi, F. “The Development of a Center Cell Structure in Bonded Aluminum for the Ferrari 408 Research Vehicle SAE 890717
- Sakura, T. “Application of Finite Element Analysis of Structural Crashworthiness for Body Design Stage” SAE 891225
- Ginsberg, M. Katnik, R. “Improving Vectorization of a Crashworthiness Code” SAE 891985
- Igarashi, M. “1989 Suzuki Sidekick/Geo Tracker Body Structure Analysis” SAE 892536
- Hunter, J. “I-DEAS improves Jaguar XJ-S convertible, Automotive Engineering” April 1990
- Nakagawa, K. Ootsubo, T. “Crash Simulation of a Passenger Car” SAE 900464
- McGregor, I. Seeds, A. Nardini, D. “The Design of Impact Absorbing Members for Aluminum Structured Vehicles” SAE 900796
- Yagawa, G. Yoshimura, S. Nakao, K. Tsuru, D. Ohji, M. “Development of an Automatic Mesh Generation System of Shell Structure Based on Fuzzy Knowledge Processing” SAE 912173
- Mizuno, R. Nishio, S. Igarashi, M. “Development of Optimal Design Analysis System for Three dimension Shell Structure” SAE 912174
- Khalil, T.B. Wasko, R.J. Hallquist, J.O. Stillman, D.J. “Finite Element Simulation of Airbag Deployment and Interactions With an Occupant Model Using DYNA3D” 13 th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles 1991 Paris, France
- Igarashi, M. Nagai, K. “Various Aspects on Crashworthiness Calculations” 13 th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles 1991 Paris, France
- Giavotto, V. Sala, G. “Crash Performance of RTM Composites for Automotive Applications” Materials Innovation and Their Applications in the Transportation Industry 1991 Torino, Italy
- Langdon, M.G. “Simulation of Side Impact on Cars” SAE Trans. 205 D2
- Nishimura, I. Sakurai, T. “Prediction of the Crashworthiness of Vehicle Body Aided Computer” SAE 912581
- Park, K.H. Shin, S.H. Cho, H.S. Jinn, J.T. “Application of the Finite Element Method for Improvement of Vehicle Crashworthiness” SAE 912582
- Mizuno, R. Nishio, S. Igarashi, M. “Development of Optimal Design Analysis System for Three Dimension Shell Structure” SAE 912174
- Ni, X. Lasry, D. Huag, E. Hoffman, R. “Advances in Problem-Adaptive Occupant Modeling with PAM-SAFE” 13 th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles 1991 Paris, France
- Benedetto, A. Bigi, D. Gilardi, M. Montacchini, L. “Side Impact Simulation” 3 rd International Conference Innovation and Reliability in Automotive Design and Testing 1992 Firenze, Italy
- Piano, L. Moruzzi, P. Pidello, A. “CAE Tools for Mission Simulation Analysis of Car Body Structures” 3 rd International Conference Innovation and Reliability in Automotive Design Testing 1992 Firenze, Italy
- Kaiser, A. “Some Examples of Numerical Simulation in Vehicle Safety Development” SAE 921074
- Dandekar, B. Van, V. “Transient Dynamic Analysis of an Automotive Bumper System” SAE 921076
- Schriever, T. Alber, P. “Development of Energy Absorbing Front Underrun Guard for Trucks” Road Traffic Safety 1993 Munich, Germany
- “CAE Techniques in Body Structures and Surfaces” Automotive Engineer 18 2 16 9
- Mizuno, K. Yonezawa, H. Toyofuku, Y. Irie, Y. Tateishi, M. Maeda, K. “Study of Side Impact Collision by Dynamic Model” JSAE Autumn Convention 1993 Nagoya, Japan
- Inotani, F. “Study of Basic Vehicle Body Structure Using Structural Optimization Technique” JSAE Autumn Convention 1993 Nagoya, Japan
- Kitagawa, Y. Hagiwara, I. “Crash Simulation” Journal of the Society of Automotive Engineers of Japan 47 4 57 5
- Nishio, S. Amir, H. Igarashi, M. “Development of 3D-Shell Structural Design Optimization System (SOPT), and its application” JSAE Spring Convention 1993 Kanagawa, Japan
- Kumagai, K. Kabeshita, Y. Enomoto, H. Shimojima, S. “An Analysis Method for Rollover Strength of Bus Structures” 14 th International Technical Conference on Enhanced Safety of Vehicles 1994 Munich, Germany
- Kitagawa, Y. Hagiwara, I. Torigaki, T. “Crash Analysis of Vehicle Body Structures Using a Buckling Sensitivity Analysis” 14 th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles 1994 Munich, Germany
- Ricardo, L. “Structural Analysis of the Joint B-Pillar x Roof of Passenger Car” SAE 952240
- Mahmood, H. Baccouche, M. Bakkar, J. “Designing for Offset Crash: A Trade-Off in Constraints” SAE 951075
- Piatak, M. Sheh, M. Young, S. Chen, J. “Using Nonlinear Finite Element Method in Convertible Crashworthiness Design” SAE 951077
- Logan, R. Perfect, S. Parkinson, R. “Energy Absorption in Aluminum Extrusions for a Spaceframe Chassis” SAE 951079
- Lakshminarayan, V. Wang, H. Williams, W.J. Harajli, Y. Chen, S. “Application of CAE Nonlinear Crash Analysis to Aluminum Automotive Crashworthiness Design” SAE 951080
- Faruque, O. Marvasti, M. “Crash Analysis Methodology for Brittle Material” SAE 951082
- Syamal, P. Yang, C.J. “Crashworthiness Simulation, Design and Development of Cross-Car Stiffener Subsystem” SAE 951083
- Syamal, P. Bhatti, M. “Rear Full Overlap High Speed Car-to-Car Impact Simulation” SAE 951085
- Shyu, S. Mani, A. Krishnaswamy, P. Conroy, R. Shermetaro, M. Exner, G. “Designing Energy Absorbing Steering Wheels Through Finite Element Impact Simulation” SAE 931844
- Renaudin, F. Guillemot, H. Lavaste, F. Skalli, W. Lesage, F. Pecheux, C. “A 3-D Finite Element Model of Pelvis in Side Impact” 37 th Stapp Car Crash Conference 1993 San Antonio, Texas, USA
- Eppinger, R. Kleinberger, M. Morgan, R. Khaewpong, N. Bandak, F. Haffner, M. “Advanced Injury Criteria and Crash Evaluation Techniques” 14 th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles 1994 Munich, Germany
- Plank, G. Kleinberger, M. Eppinger, R. “Finite Element Modeling and Analysis of Thorax/Restraint System Interaction” 14 th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles 1994 Munich, Germany
- Maurer, D. Kohlhoff, S. DuBois, P. “Advances in Side Impact Simulation Procedures” 14 th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles 1994 Munich, Germany
- Ruckert, J. Marcault, P. Schlosser, J. Lasry, D. Haug, E. Roger, J. Cesari, D. Bermond, F. Bouquet, R. “Advances in Finite Element Modeling of the EUROSID-1 Dummy” 14 th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles 1994 Munich, Germany
- Franz, J. Hoffmann, R. Vasen, J. Hillenbrand, K. “Numerical and Experimental Simulation of Different Load Cases in Side Impacts” 14 th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles 1994 Munich, Germany
- DiMasi, F. Eppinger, R. Bandak, F. “Computational Analysis of Head Impact Response Under Car Crash Loadings” SAE 952718
- Tilakasiri, A. Johnson, D. “Super Computer Simulation of Vehicles and Occupants for Front and Side Impact Protection at Ford” The European Automotive Industry Meets the Challenges of the Year 2000 - 5 th International Congress of the European Automobile Engineers Cooperation 1995 Strasbourgh, France
- Botkin, M. Lust, R. “A Neural Network Application to Shape Optimization” SAE 951102
- Shimoda, M. Azegami, H. Sakurai, R. “A Traction Method Approach to Shape Optimization of Linear Elastic Structures Subject to Multiple Loading Conditions” SAE 951103
- Harzheim, L. Graf, G. “Optimization of Engineering Components with the SKO Method” SAE 951104
- Pant, R. Cheng, J. “Integration of Vehicle Interior Models into Crash Up-Front Process with Optimization” SAE 951107