This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Life Cycle Value Assessment (LCVA) Comparison of Conventional Gasoline and Reformulated Gasoline
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Fuel choices are being made today by consumers, industry and government. One such choice is whether to use reformulated gasoline to replace regular unleaded gasoline. A second choice involves the source of crude oil, with synthetic crude oil from tar sands currently expanding its share of the Canadian supply. Decision makers usually work with the direct economic consequences of their fuel choice. However, they generally lack the knowledge to measure environmental aspects of different fuel systems. This paper uses Life Cycle Value Assessment (LCVA) to demonstrate how the life cycle environmental aspects can be compared for alternative fuel choices.
LCVA is an engineering decision making tool which provides a framework for the decision maker to consider the key economic and environmental impacts for the entire life cycle of alternative products or process systems. This paper presents an LCVA case-study comparing conventional gasoline and reformulated gasoline as produced from energy resources in Alberta, Canada. A fifteen percent MTBE blended gasoline is compared to regular unleaded gasoline using data from publicly accessible sources. In addition, this paper compares conventional crude oil to tar sands synthetic crude as hydrocarbon sources for the two gasoline fuels.
The study concludes that the only significant advantage of MTBE-blended gasoline over regular unleaded gasoline is a reduction of hazardous air pollutants at the combustion stage. Considering the entire life cycle, there is no significant difference between the fuels in ground-level ozone precursors while MTBE-blended gasoline is at a slight disadvantage with respect to acid rain precursors, greenhouse gases and particulate matter emissions. Comparing energy sources, fuel produced from tar sands crude produces substantially more acid rain precursors and greenhouse gases in the upstream processes. However, in the context of the overall fuel system, the increase is relatively small (less than 5% in best case).
One aspect of the sensitivity analysis compared various approaches to reducing environmental impact. This showed that reducing vehicle fuel consumption would reduce environmental impact more than comparable improvements in emission rates at the various steps of the process.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Raynolds, M., Checkel, M., and Fraser, R., "Life Cycle Value Assessment (LCVA) Comparison of Conventional Gasoline and Reformulated Gasoline," SAE Technical Paper 980468, 1998, https://doi.org/10.4271/980468.Also In
References
- Alberta Energy and Utilities Board (A.E.U.B.) Alberta's Energy Resources 1996 in Review . A.E.U.B. Calgary 1996
- Reformulated gasoline in 1995 . Energy Norwalk, Connecticut 20 1 Feb 1995 4 7 1995
- Battelle Memorial Institute CleanFleet Final Report - Volume 7 Vehicle Emissions . Battelle Columbus, Ohio 1995 U.S. D.O.E. O.S.T.I.
- Battelle Memorial Institute CleanFleet Final Report - Volume 4 Fuel Economy . Battelle Columbus, Ohio 1995 U.S. D.O.E. O.S.T.I.
- Bovar Report 1: Sources of Atmospheric Emissions in the Athabasca Oil Sands Region . 1996 Alberta Environmental Protection
- CE Alberta BioClean Ltd. Application for Industrial Development Permit for the Alberta BioClean Project - AEUB . 1997 Alberta Environmental Protection
- Clean Air Strategy for Alberta (C.A.S.A.) Report to the Ministers . CASA, Gov't of Alberta Edmonton 1991
- Deluchi, M.A. Emissions of Greenhouse Gases from the Use of Transportation Fuels and Electricity - Vol. 1 and 2 . Center for Transportation Research, Energy Systems Division, Argonne National Laboratory 1991 1993
- Energy Resources Conservation Board (E.R.C.B.) Alberta Oil Supply 1994 - 2005 Update . E.R.C.B.,Gov't of Alberta Calgary 1994
- Jaques, Art Fossil Fuel Energy Trade & Greenhouse Gas Emissions . Environment Canada 1997
- Monenco AGRA Inc. Development of a Database for Full Fuel Cycle Emissions From Electric Power Generation in Alberta . The Full Fuel Cycle Emissions Analysis Industry/Government Consortium 1994
- Nobert, M. National Pollutant Release Inventory - Summary Report 1994 . Environment Canada Ottawa 1996
- Raynolds, M.A. Checkel, M.D. Fraser, R.A. Macintosh, R.A. Life Cycle Value Assessment (LCVA) for Alternative Transportation Fuel Decisions Proceedings of the 1997 Total Life Cycle Conference - Life Cycle Management and Assessment (Part 1), (paper 971169 ), SAE P-310 , Society of Automotive Engineers, Inc. Warrendale, PA 1997
- Statistics Canada Human Activity and the Environment 1994 . Statistics Canada Ottawa 1994
- World Business Council for Sustainable, Development Eco-efficient Leadership for Improved Economic and Environmental Performance WBCSD Geneva 1996
- Personal correspondence with Alberta EnviroFuels March 1997
- Personal correspondence with Methanex March 1997
- Raynolds, M.A. Checkel, M.D. Fraser, R.A. Macintosh, R.A. Uncertainty, Sensitivity and Data Quality Assessment for Life Cycle Value Assessment (LCVA) Studies paper 980479 SAE International Congress March 1998
- Industry Canada The Socio-Economic Impacts of Adopting Tighter Motor Vehicle Emission Standards and Fuel Requirements Industry Canada 1996
- Campbell, B. Dufay, L. Macintosh, R. Comparative Analysis of Employment from Air Emission Reduction Measures Environment Canada- Global Air Issues Branch, Pembina Institute for Appropriate Development 1997