This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Natural Gas and Diesel Transit Bus Emissions: Review and Recent Data
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Natural Gas engines are viewed as an alternative to diesel power in the quest to reduce heavy duty vehicle emissions in polluted urban areas. In particular, it is acknowledged that natural gas has the potential to reduce the inventory of particulate matter, and this has encouraged the use of natural gas engines in transit bus applications. Extensive data on natural gas and diesel bus emissions have been gathered using two Transportable Heavy Duty Vehicle Emissions Testing Laboratories, that employ chassis dynamometers to simulate bus inertia and road load. Most of the natural gas buses tested prior to 1997 were powered by Cummins L-10 engines, which were lean-burn and employed a mechanical mixer for fuel introduction. The Central Business District (CBD) cycle was used as the test schedule. The potential of these natural gas engines to reduce emissions significantly was demonstrated, but vehicles that had strayed from a proper state of tune were found to emit high levels of carbon monoxide, and could emit oxides of nitrogen at higher levels than their diesel counterparts, emphasizing the need for careful maintenance. Recently, one of the Transportable Laboratories tested ten compressed natural gas and three diesel buses in Atlanta, GA and seven diesel buses in Flint, MI. The natural gas vehicles were powered by Detroit Diesel Series 50 G 275hp engines, which employ lean burn, with electronically managed fueling without feedback control. CBD cycle emissions data showed that the natural gas buses offered lower levels of oxide of nitrogen emissions than their diesel counterparts, and that their particulate emissions were exceptionally low. Oxides of nitrogen emissions ranged from 26.1 to 60.4 grams/kilometer while carbon monoxide emissions were consistently close to 14.5 grams/kilometer for all of the Atlanta natural gas buses. Data are also available from these buses to show the methane versus non-methane split of hydrocarbons, and data also show the emissions reduction associated with correcting an ignition system fault on one bus. In addition, the effect of the test cycle on diesel bus emissions has been discussed.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Clark, N., Gautam, M., Lyons, D., Bata, R. et al., "Natural Gas and Diesel Transit Bus Emissions: Review and Recent Data," SAE Technical Paper 973203, 1997, https://doi.org/10.4271/973203.Also In
References
- Pataky, G.M. Baumgard, K.J. Gratz, L.D. Bagley, ST. Leddy, D.G. Johnson, J.H. “Effects of an Oxidation Catalytic Converter on Regulated and Unregulated Diesel Emissions.” SAE Paper 940243
- Bagley, S.T. Baumgard, K.J. Gratz, L.D. Johnson, J.H. Leddy, D.G. Characterization of Fuel and Aftertreatment Device Effects on Diesel Emissions “Health Effect Institute, Research Report Number 76” September 1996
- Monn, CH. Braendli, O. Schaeppi, G. Schindler, C. Ackermann-Liebrich, U. Leuenberger, P. Spaldia Team “Particulate Matter < 10 mm (PM 10 ) and Total Suspended Particulates (TSP) in Urban, Rural, and Alpine Air in Switerland,” Atmospheric Environment. 29 19 2565 2573 1995
- Braun, C.H. Ackermann, U. Schwartz, J. Gnehm, H.P. Rutishauser, M. Wanner, H.U. “Air Pollution and Respiratory Symptoms in Pre-School Children,” Am. Rev., Respir. 145 42 47 1992
- Pope, C.A. Dockery, D.W. “Acute Health Effects of PM Pollution on symptomatic and Asymptomatic Children.” Am. Rev. Respir. Dis. 145 1123 1128 1992
- Dockery, D.W. Pope W.A. Xu, Z. Spengler, J.D. Ware, J.H. Fay, M.E. Ferris, B.G. Speizer, F.E. “An Association between Air Pollution and Morality in six U.S. Cities,” New Engl.J. Med., 329 1753 1759 1993
- Kreyling, W.G. “Is the Mass Concentration of Particulate Air Pollution the Appropriate Parameter for Respiratory Health Effects?,” Zbl. Hyg. 159 198 199 1994
- Donaldson, K. “Effects of Ultrafine Titanium Dioxide on Epithelial Cells,” Meeting of Aerosol Soc. Birmingham 1994
- Jones, A. “Particulate Air Pollution and Respiratory Disorders,” Meeting of the Aerosol Soc. Birmingham 1994
- Kao, K.S. Friedlander, S.K. “Frequency Distribution of PM 10 , Chemical Components and their Sources,” Enviro. Sci. Technol., 29 198 199
- NESCAUM “Heavy Duty Engine Emissions in the Northeast States for Coordinated Air Use Management,” Boston, Mass. May 1997
- Spengler, J.D. Brauer, M. Koutrakis, P. 1990 “Acid Air and Health,” Envir. Sci. Technol., 24 946 956
- Mauderly, J.L. Jones. R.K. McClellan, R.O. Henderson. R.F. Griffith, W.C. “Carcinogenicity of Diesel Exhaust Inhaled Chronically by Rats,” Proceedings of the Int'l Satellite Symp. On Toxicological Effects of Emissions from Diesel Engines Elsevier Sci. Publ. N.Y. 397 409 1986
- Iwal, K. Udagawa, T. Yamagishi, M. Yamada, H. “Long-Term Inhalation Studies of Diesel Exhaust on F344 SPF Rats,” Proc., Int'l Satellite Symp. On Toxicological Effects of Emissions from Diesel Engines Elsevier Sci. Pub. N.Y. 349 360 1986
- McClellan. R.O. “Health Effects of Diesel Exhaust: A Case Study in Risk Assessment,” Am. In. Hyg. Assoc. J., 3 332 1986
- Sharp, C. Ullman, T. Stamper, K. “Transient Emissions form Two Natural Gas-Fueled Heavy-Duty Engines,” SAE Paper 932819 1993
- Clark, N.N. Gadapati, C.J. Kelley, K. White., C.L. Lyons, D.W. Wang. W. Gautam, M. Bata, R.M. “Comparative Emissions form Natural Gas and Diesel Buses,” SAE Paper 952746 1995
- Wang, W. Gautam, M. Sun, X. Bata, R. Clark, N. Palmer, M. Lyons, D. “Emissions Comparisons of Twenty-Six Heavy-Duty Vehicles Operated on Conventional and Alternative Fuels,” SAE Paper 932952 1993
- Wool, W. Jackson, M. Bassett, T. “An Evaluation of Compressed Natural Gas Buses in Small Transit Operations,” SAE Paper 960769 1996
- Clark, N.N. Wang, W.G. Lyons, D.W. Gautan, M. Bata, R.M. “Troubleshooting High Emissions From In-Service Alternative Fueled Buses,” Windsor Workshop on Alternative Fuels (Proceedings), 421 437 Toronto June 1996
- Clark, N.N. Mott, G.E. Atkinson, C.M. deJong, R.J. Atkinson, R.J. Latvakosky, T. Traver, M.L. “Effect of Fuel Composition on the Operation of a Lean Burn Natural Gas Engine,” SAE Paper 952560 1995
- Machiele, P.A. “Heavy-Duty Vehicle Emission Conversion Factors II (1962-2000),” 1989
- Chandler, K.L. Malcosky, N.D. Motta, R.C. Norton, P. Kelly, K. Schumacher, L. Lyons, D. “Alternative Fuel Transit Bus Evaluation Program Results,” SAE Paper 961082 1996
- Chandler, K.L. Malcosky, N.D. Motta, R.C. Kelley, K.J. Norton, P.M. Schumacher, L.G. “Final Alternative Fuel Transit Bus Evaluation Results,” Columbus December 1996
- Messer, J.T. Clark, N.N. Lyons, D.W. “Measurement Delays and Modal Analysis for a Heavy - Duty Transportable Emissions Testing Laboratory,” SAE Paper 950218 1995
- Clark, N.N. Lyons, D.W. “Emissions from CNG and Diesel Refuse Haulers Using Six Engine Types in New York City,” Seventh CRC On-Road Vehicle Emissions Workshop 5 49 5 64 San Diego April 1997
- Clark, N.N. Lyons, D.W. Gautam, M. Bata, R.M. Wang, W.G. “Field Emissions Testing of Heavy Duty Natural Gas Vehicles,” Windsor Workshop on Transportations Fuels Windsor, Ontario 1997