This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Life Cycle Value Assessment (LCVA) for Alternative Transportation Fuel Decisions
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Transportation, with its high energy consumption, is commonly recognized as a major contributor to local, regional, and global environmental impacts. With around 95% of transportation energy originating from petroleum and an increasing emphasis on the associated environmental impacts, alternative transportation fuels are receiving great attention from industry, government, researchers, and the public. When the motivation for developing alternative fuels is to reduce environmental impact, a rigorous tool is needed for comparing the effects of very different alternative and conventional fuels. Such an evaluation tool must consider not only the effects of fuel combustion, but also the effects of producing, refining/processing, distributing, and disposing of wastes associated with that fuel… in other words, the life cycle effects of the fuel.
This paper develops a Life Cycle Value Assessment (LCVA) methodology for comparing the potential life cycle environmental impacts of automotive fuels. Unlike various life cycle assessments (LCA) and “full-fuel-cycle” analyses previously reported, this treatment is designed specifically for automotive fuels. It gives the ability to assess the potential life cycle environmental impacts and key economic aspects of different fuels. It also has an open architecture which allows ready application of new research data or varying economic factors. Potential environmental impacts are calculated using different stressor categories with impact ranging from global to local: 1. Greenhouse Gases. 2. Acid Rain Precursors. 3. Ground Level Ozone Precursors. 4. Hazardous Air Pollutants. The paper describes the LCVA methodology and background for a comparison of conventional gasoline, ethanol-blended gasoline, and natural gas.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Raynolds, M., Checkel, M., Fraser, R., and Macintosh, R., "Life Cycle Value Assessment (LCVA) for Alternative Transportation Fuel Decisions," SAE Technical Paper 971169, 1997, https://doi.org/10.4271/971169.Also In
References
- Environmental Leaders 1 - Voluntary Commitments to Action on Toxics through ARET Hull, Quebec 1995
- Control of Hazardous Air Pollutants in OECD Countries OECD Paris 1995
- Alternative Transportation Fuels in Ontario Ontario Ministry of Environment and Energy 1994
- Cars and Climate Change OECD/DIA 1993
- Air Quality Committee. Canada - United States Air Quality Agreement - 1994 Progress Report International Joint Commission 1994
- Bakst, J.S. Lacke, C.J. Weitz, K.A. Warren, J.L Guidelines for Assessing the Quality of Life-Cycle Inventory Data Office of Solid Waste - US EPA Washington, DC March 1995
- Bell, S.R. Gupta, M. Greening, L.A. Full-Fuel-Cycle Approach to Vehicle Emissions Modeling: A Case Study of Gasoline in the Southeastern Region of the United States Energy Sources 17 535 551 Taylor & Francis 1995
- Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment (CCME) Management Plant for Nitrogen Oxides and Volatile Organic Compounds Phase I CCME 1990
- Clean Air Strategy for Alberta (CASA) Report to the Ministers CASA Edmonton 1991
- Darrow, K.G. Light Duty Vehicle Full Fuel Cycle Emissions Analysis - Topical Report Energy International Inc., Gas Research Institute 1994
- Deluchi, M.A. Emissions of Greenhouse Gases from the Use of Transportation Fuels and Electricity - Vol. 1 and 2 Center for Transportation Research, Energy Systems Division, Argonne National Laboratory 1991 1993
- Fava, J. Consoli, F. Denison, R. Dickson, K. Mohin, T. Vigon, B. A Conceptual Framework for Life-Cycle Impact Assessment SETAC 1992
- Fava, J. Jensen, A.A. Lindfors, L. Pomper, S. De Smet, B Warren, J. Life Cycle Assessment Data Quality: A Conceptual Framework SETAC 1992
- Flavin, C. Lenssen, N. Power Surge - Guide to the Coming Energy Revolution The Worldwatch Environmental Alert Series W.W. Norton & Company New York 1994
- Heath, Michelle Alternative Transportation Fuels: Natural Gas, Propane, Methanol & Ethanol Compared with Gasoline & Diesel Canadian Energy Research Institute Calgary 1991
- Husseini, A. Canadian Raw Materials Database: Life Cycle Inventory Methodology - Plus 1116 Canadian Standards Assciation (CSA) Etobicoke, Ontario 1996
- International Energy Agency (IEA) Comparing Energy Technologies OECD 1996
- Jacques Whitford Environment Ltd. Technical Briefing Note - Automotive Fuels Environmental Choice Program - Draft Report 1994
- Johnston, P. Melo, O. Khan, A. Internal Environmental Cost Review of Southwest Hydro Ontario Hydro, Environment and Sustainable Development Division 1996
- Knoepfel, I.H. A Framework for Environmental Impact Assessment of Long-Distance Energy Transport Systems 21 7 8 693 702 Elsevier Science Ltd. UK 1996
- Lang, C. Yarwood, G. Lalonde, F. Bloxam, R. Environmental and Health Benefits of Cleaner Vehicles and Fuels CCME 1995
- Ledwell, T.A. Physics of the Environment with Emphasis on Global Changes Due to Energy Use 1995
- Lindberg, S.E. Page, A.L. Norton, S.A. Acidic Precipitation Volume 3 Sources, Deposition, and Canopy Interactions Springer-Verlag New York 1990
- Manahan, S.E. Environmental Chemistry - Sixth Edition Lewis Publishers London 1994
- Nobert, M. National Pollutant Release Inventory - Summary Report 1994 Environment Canada Ottawa 1996
- R.F. Webb Corporation Ltd. The Environmental Effects of Transportation Fuels Natural Resources Canada Ottawa 1993
- Segal, M. Ethanol Fuel and Global Warming CRS Report for Congress Library of Congress 1989
- Tyson, K.S. Riley, C.J. Humphreys, K.K. Fuel Cycle Evaluations of Biomass-Ethanol and Reformulated Gasoline Fuels I&II National Renewable Energy Lab. Golden, CO 1992
- Weidema, B. P. Wesnoes, M.S. Data Quality management for life cycle inventories - an example of using lata quality indicators SETAC World Congress November 5-9 1995 1995
- Senate of Canada April 6 1995 Queens Printer Ottawa 1995
- Pigeon R. Natural Resources Canada November 1996
- Hornung Robert Pembina Institute for Appropriate Development December 1996
- Chan W. Dr. Ontario Ministry of Environment and Energy October 1996
- Freeman G. Dr. Professor of Chemistry at the University of Alberta October 1996
- Personal communication Chan Lorn Mr. Alberta Environmental Protection October 1996