This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Crashworthiness and Compatibility of Low Mass Vehicles in Collisions
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Reducing the weight of vehicles could be a strong means of reducing fuel consumption in urban traffic. Published accident and injury statistics however show an inverse correlation of vehicle mass against injury severity in car to car collisions, above all in head-on collisions. This inverse correlation is in part caused by current crash test standards, where compatibility in collisions between cars of different size and weight is not a requirement. Compatibility in frontal collisions demands for significantly different deceleration-time curves in rigid barrier impacts for cars with different weight. Low mass vehicles (LMV) must meet compatibility criteria to comply with current injury criteria in real car to car collisions. Cars designed according to compatibility criteria can change future accident and injury statistics in a way that injury severity in LMVs can be reduced significantly.
This study shows, that head-on collisions at closing speeds of up to 100 km/h with a mass ratio of 1:2 of the collision opponents can be survived with occupant loads well below the limits of actual injury criteria (FMVSS 208), if compatibility requirements are met with regard to car structure as well as restraint systems.
Recommended Content
Authors
- P. Frei - Working Group on Accident Mechanics at the Universities Zürich
- R. Kaeser - Working Group on Accident Mechanics at the Universities Zürich
- R. Hafner - Working Group on Accident Mechanics at the Universities Zürich
- M. Schmid - Working Group on Accident Mechanics at the Universities Zürich
- A. Dragan - Working Group on Accident Mechanics at the Universities Zürich
- L. Wingeier - Working Group on Accident Mechanics at the Universities Zürich
- M. H. Muser - Working Group on Accident Mechanics at the Universities Zürich
- P. F. Niederer - Working Group on Accident Mechanics at the Universities Zürich
- F. H. Walz - Working Group on Accident Mechanics at the Universities Zürich
Topic
Citation
Frei, P., Kaeser, R., Hafner, R., Schmid, M. et al., "Crashworthiness and Compatibility of Low Mass Vehicles in Collisions," SAE Technical Paper 970122, 1997, https://doi.org/10.4271/970122.Also In
Occupant Protection and Injury Assessment in the Automotive Crash Environment
Number: SP-1231; Published: 1997-02-24
Number: SP-1231; Published: 1997-02-24
References
- Evans L. Frick M. Driver fatality risk in two-car crashes Dependence on masses of driven and striking car Proc. Conf. ESV 13 1991
- Appel H. 1972 221ff
- Puleo G. Small Vehicle Structural Design Trans. SAE 82 1973 SAE 730075
- Niederer P. et al Occupant Safety of Low-Mass Vehicles Proc. Conf. Stapp 37 1993 1ff SAE 933107
- Muser M. et al. Optimised restraint systems for Low Mass Vehicles Proc. Conf. STAPP 1996 SAE 962435
- Kaeser R. et al. Passive Safety Potential of Low Mass Vehicles Proc. Conf. IRCOBI 1995 337ff