This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Evaluation of a Proposed ATV Design Modification
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Successful development of a product requires the consideration and balancing of many design parameters. Proposals to modify designs that have been fully implemented and put into production are often made by people who were not involved in the original design process. Such proposals, commonly focusing on a specific aspect of the product, must be evaluated in the context of the overall product and its intended use by consumers; a design change may improve performance in one area but compromise performance in another, or even introduce new problem areas.
As a case in point, several proposals have been made for operator protection systems with the claim that they would reduce the frequency and severity of injuries associated with All Terrain Vehicle (ATV) operation. For example, Johnson, Carpenter, Wright & Nelson (1991) considered selected accident modes and proposed a set of design changes involving a rollover protection system (ROPS) and significant vehicle modifications. In this paper, the design concept is evaluated in more detail.
A full-scale operating model of the proposed four-wheel vehicle prototype was built; systematic comparisons to ATVs were made considering mobility, utility, performance, and occupant protection. It was found that the proposed vehicle modifications in fact produce a new vehicle type with significantly reduced utility and performance compared to ATVs, without the likelihood of reducing the accident and injury risk associated with the use of the vehicle. Unlike existing ATVs, the Johnson et al. design does not appear to be a viable approach to balancing utility and safety. This outcome is consistent with other analyses and with the general conclusions reached by the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC).
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Investigation of the Net Safety Impact of an Occupant Protection System From All-Terrain Vehicles |
Technical Paper | Occupant Protection for All-Terrain Vehicles |
Technical Paper | A Safer ATV |
Authors
Citation
Piziali, R., Fowler, G., Merala, R., Grewal, D. et al., "Evaluation of a Proposed ATV Design Modification," SAE Technical Paper 940276, 1994, https://doi.org/10.4271/940276.Also In
References
- Bowman, B. L. Rounds, D. A. 1988 “Restraint System Usage in the Traffic Population.” 1987 Annual Report National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
- Consumer Product Safety Commission 1990 “All-Terrain Vehicle Voluntary Standards/Lateral Stability Status Report,” September 1990
- Consumer Product Safety Commission 1991a “Briefing Package on All-Terrain Vehicles,” March 1991
- Consumer Product Safety Commission 1991b “All-Terrain Vehicles: Termination of Rulemaking Proceeding” Federal Register 56 September 18 1991 47166 47173
- Harill, E.D. 1990 Honorable Doug Barnard, Jr. in response to Johnson ROPS
- IASS 1985 “Maneuver Analysis: A Safety Program for Fork-lift Truck Operator Protection” Institute For Advanced Safety Studies (IASS)
- Johnson, F.H. 1991 Hagelsieb v. Honda February 18 1991
- Johnson, F.H. Wright, R.R. Carpenter, T.G. Nelson, R. 1991 “A Safer ATV,” SAE Paper # 911945
- Ouellet, J.V. 1990 “Appropriate and Inappropriate Strategies for Injury Reduction in Motorcycle Accidents,” Rider-Passenger Protection in Motorcycle Collisions
- Piziali, R. L. Paver, J.G. Merala, R. Fries, R. Fowler, G.F. McCarthy, R.L. 1992 “Evaluation of an Occupant Protection System for All-Terrain Vehicles,” Proceedings of the ASME Winter Meeting
- Piziali, R. L. Ayres, T.J. Paver, J.G. Fowler, G.F. McCarthy, R.L. 1993 “Investigation of the Net Safety Impact of an Occupant Protection System For All-Terrain Vehicles,” SAE Paper # 930208
- Takeuchi, O. 1989 O'Berg v. Honda April 18 1989
- Weir, D.H. Zellner, J.W. 1986 “An Introduction to the Operational Characteristics of All-Terrain-Vehicles,” SAE Paper # 860225
- Wong, J. Y. Theory of Ground Vehicles John Wiley & Sons New York 1978
- Woodward, J. L. Swan, S. 1980 “ROPS Field Performance - A Status Report.” SAE Paper No. 800679