This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Operating Vehicle Roll Stability
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
It is well understood and supported by more than a decade of statistical investigation that vehicles involved in on-road rollovers are generally out of control (e.g. spinout, side slide) prior to the roll, and that lateral stability is the primary vehicle parameter governing such occurrences. Although a rollover is unstable from lift-off to tip-over, an impulse of sufficient duration is required to input the work necessary to lift the center of gravity to a position over the leading wheels. The force in this impulse is, absent a geometric trip, limited to friction between the vehicle tires and the travelled surface. The coefficient of friction of a tire sliding laterally on dry pavement is generally at or below 0.9, although in certain conditions of unusual tire shoulder wear somewhat higher friction has been observed. Therefore vehicle side stability above this level (0.9 at GVW) is a reasonable design criterion for light vehicles. Statistical studies have been based on geometric stability (half track/center of gravity height) as an approximate indicator. However, the actual parameter of concern is, of course, the operating vehicle stability, including the effects of suspension and tire compliance. General Motors, approximately 20 years ago, found the typical operating stability of its vehicles to be about 75% of geometric stability. To facilitate testing for regulatory purposes, the presently favored technique (NHTSA, ECE) is the tilt table. An analytic model including detailed characterization of suspension components and tires is presented to quantitatively account for both suspension and tire compliance in reducing geometric stability to operating stability, and also to quantitatively relate tilt table stability to the operating stability of actual concern. Further, available empirical data shows that the effect of tire compliance is substantive and is of concern in tilt table design.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | A Primer on Nonlinear, Steady-State Vehicle Turning Behavior |
Technical Paper | Field Testing and Computer Simulation Analysis of Ground Vehicle Dynamic Stability |
Technical Paper | The Dynamic Stiffness of a Pneumatic Tire Model |
Authors
Topic
Citation
Tamny, S., "Operating Vehicle Roll Stability," SAE Technical Paper 932945, 1993, https://doi.org/10.4271/932945.Also In
References
- Ervin, R. D. et al “Vehicle Handling Performance” HSRI 1972
- Snyder, R. G. et al “On-Road Crash Experience of Utility Vehicles” HSRI 1980
- Smith, S. R. “Analysis of Fatal Rollover Accidents in Utility Vehicles” NHTSA 1982
- Reinfurt, D. W. et al “A Further Look at Utility Vehicle Rollovers” HSRC University of North Carolina 1984
- Robertson, L. S. Kelley, B. “The Role of Stability in Rollover-Initiated Fatal Motor-Vehicle Crashes Under On-Road Driving Conditions” AIEG 1986
- Harwin, E. A. Brewer, H. K. “Analysis of the Relationship Between Vehicle Rollover Stability and Rollover Risk Using the NHTSA CARDfile Accident Database” NHTSA 1987
- Terhune, K. W. “A Study of Light Truck and Passenger Car Rollover and Ejection in Single-Vehicle Crashes” Franklin Research Center Arvin/Calspan 1988
- Data Link “Rollover in Motor Vehicle Accidents” NHTSA 1989
- Mengert, P. et al “Statistical Estimation of Rollover Risk” NHTSA 1989
- NHTSA “Relationship Between Rollover and Vehicle Factors” NHTSA 1991
- Uthe, R. J. “Letter to Suzuki Motor Co. presenting Geometric Stability Related to Rollover Accident Percentage - 1983 GM 1986
- Clark, S. K. “Mechanics of Pneumatic Tires” GPO 1982
- Baker, J. S. “Traffic Accident Investigation Manual” Traffic Institute Northwestern University 1975
- Collins, J. C. “Accident Reconstruction” C. C. Thomas 1979
- Noga, T. Oppenheim, T. “CRASH3 User's Guide and Technical Manual” NHTSA 1981
- HSRI “Vehicle Handling Performance” HSRI 1972
- HSRI “Limit Handling Performance as Influenced by Degradation of Steering & Suspension Systems” HSRI 1972
- GM “Comments of General Motors Corporation on Notice of Proposed Rule Making - Rollover Resistance” General Motors 1973
- Carr, L. C. “Letter to J. R. Treat, Esq. presenting record of Ice/Pavement Trip Tests of February 19-21, 1988” Carr Engineering 1988
- NHTSA “An Evaluation of Static Rollover Propensity Measures” NHTSA 1991