This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
An Intelligent Systems Approach to Active Structural Acoustic Control
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
The objective of this paper is to review recent advances in active structural acoustic control and detail the advantages and limitations with respect to intelligent system design. The term intelligent system is used to describe a structure with both control actuators and error sensors either bonded to the surface or embedded within the structure for modifying the response under the direction of an adaptive control algorithm. The concept of an intelligent structure for vibration and structural acoustic control applications can be attributed primarily to recent advances in active material technology as well as increased speed in digital signal processors. Basic concepts in structural acoustics are reviewed in this work to familiarize the audience with the fundamental problem. Methods of modeling piezoelectric control actuators and error sensors for vibration and structural acoustic control applications are presented with a review of various design approaches. Alternative control approaches are discussed, targeting performance advantages and limitations with respect to the algorithms. Examples of recent applications are presented to convey the potential of this developing technology. Results from recent research efforts indicate that the basic elements of intelligent system design for active structural acoustic control are available for preliminary implementation on vehicles for land, sea, air and space.
Authors
Topic
Citation
Clark, R. and Saunders, W., "An Intelligent Systems Approach to Active Structural Acoustic Control," SAE Technical Paper 931282, 1993, https://doi.org/10.4271/931282.Also In
References
- Ackermann J. 1985 Sampled-Data Control Systems Springer-Verlag Berlin 270 271
- Bailey T. Hubbard J.E. 1985 “Distributed piezoelectric-polymer active vibration control of a cantilevered beam,” AIAA Journal of Guidance and Control 6 5 605 611
- Banks H.T. Fang W. Silcox R.J. Smith R.C. 1993 “Approximation methods for control of structural acoustics models with piezoceramic actuators,” Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures 4 1 98 116
- Baumann W.T. Ho Fu-sheng Robertshaw H.H. 1992 Journal of Acoustical Society of America 92 4 1998 2005
- Baumann W.T. Saunders W.R. Robertshaw H.H. 1991 “Active suppression of acoustic radiation from impulsively excited structures,” Journal of Acoustical Society of America 90 6 3202 3208
- Burdisso R.A. Fuller C.R. 1992(a) “Theory of feedforward controlled system eigenproperties,” Journal of Sound and Vibration 153 3 437 451
- Burdisso R.A. Fuller C.R. 1992(b) “Active Dynamic Modification of Flexible Structures,” Proceedings of the 10th International Modal Analysis Conference (IMAC) San Diego, California II 1159 1166
- Burke S.E. Hubbard J. 1987 “Active Vibration Control of a Simply Supported Beam Using a Spatially Distributed Actuator,” IEEE Control System Magazine 7 6 25 30
- Burke S.E. Hubbard J. 1991 “Distributed Transducer Vibration Control of Thin Plates,” The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 90 2 937 944
- Cady W.G. 1964 Piezoelectricity 2 Dover Publications, Inc. New York
- Chen G.S. Lurie B.J. Wada B.K. 1989 “Experimental studies of adaptive structures for precision performance,” Proceedings, 30th Structures, SDM Conference Mobile, AL 1462 1472
- Clark R.L. Fuller C.R. Wicks A.L. 1991 “Characterization of Multiple Piezoelectric Actuators for Structural Excitation,” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 90 1 346 357
- Clark R.L. Fuller C.R. 1992(a) “Experiments on Active Control of Structurally Radiated Sound Using Multiple Piezoceramic Actuators,” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 91 6 3313 3320
- Clark R.L. Fuller C.R. 1992(b) “Modal Sensing of Efficient Acoustic Radiators with PVDF Distributed Sensors in Active Structural Acoustic Approaches,” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 91 6 3321 3329
- Clark R.L. Fuller C.R. Burdisso R.A. 1992(c) “Design Approaches for Shaping Polyvinylidene Fluoride Sensors in Active Structural Acoustic Control,” Conference on Recent Advances in Adaptive and Sensory Materials and Their Applications Technomic Press Rogers C.A. Rogers C.R. 702 726
- Clark R.L. Flemming M.R. Fuller C.R. 1992(d) “Piezoelectric Actuators for Distributed Vibration Excitation of Thin Plates: A Comparison between Theory and Experiment,” Journal of Vibration and Acoustics
- Clark R.L. Fuller C.R. 1992(e) “Control of Sound Radiation with Adaptive Structures,” Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures 2 3 431 452
- Clark R.L. Fuller C.R. 1992(f) “A Model Reference Approach for Implementing Active Structural Acoustic Control,” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 92 3 1534 1544
- Clark R.L. Fuller C.R. 1992(g) “Optimal Placement of Piezoelectric Actuators and Polyvinylidene Fluoride (PVDF) Error Sensors in Active Structural Acoustic Control Approaches (ASAC),” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 92 3 1521 1533
- Clark R.L. Fuller C.R. 1992(h) “Active Structural Acoustic Control with Adaptive Structures Including Wavenumber Considerations,” The Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures 3 2 296 315 Recent Advances in Active Control of Sound and Vibration Technomic Press Rogers C.A. Fuller C.R. 507 524
- Clark R.L. 1992 “Advanced sensing techniques in active structural acoustic control,” Doctor of Philosophy Thesis Department of Mechanical Engineering, VPI&SU.
- Clark R.L. Gibbs G.P. Fuller C.R. 1993 “An Experimental Study Implementing Model Reference Active Structural Acoustic Control,” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Collins S.A. Miller D.W. von Flotow A.H. 1990 “Sensors for Structural Control Applications Using Piezoelectric Polymer Film,” MIT Report 1 83
- Collins S.A. Padilla C.E. Notestine R.J. von Flowtow A.H. Schmitz E. Ramey M. 1992 “Design, manufacture and application to space robotics of distributed piezoelectric film sensors,” Journal of Guidance and Control 15 396 403
- Crawley E.F. de Luis J. 1987 “Use of Piezoelectric Actuators as Elements of Intelligent Structures,” AIAA Journal 25 10 1373 1385
- Crawley E.F. Lazarus K.B. 1989 “Induced strain actuation of isotropic and anisotropic plates,” Proceedings, 30th SDM Conference Mobile, AI
- Crawley E.F. Anderson E.H. 1989 “Detailed modeling of piezoelectric actuation of beams,” Proceedings, 30th SDM Conference Mobile, AI
- Cunefare K. Koopmann G.H. 1991(a) “A boundary element approach to optimization of active noise control sources on three-dimensional structures Journal of Vibration and Acoustics 113 3 387 394
- Cunefare K. Koopmann G.H. 1991(b) “Global optimum active noise control: surface and farfield effects,” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 90 1 365 373
- Dimitriadis E.K. Fuller C.R. 1991 “Active Control of Sound Transmission Through Elastic Plates Using Piezoelectric Actuators,” AIAA Journal 29 11 1771 1777
- Dimitriadis E.K. Fuller C.R. Rogers C.A. January 1991 “Piezoelectric Actuators for Distributed Vibration Excitation of Thin Plates,” Journal of Vibration and Acoustics 113 57 100 107
- Elliot S.J. Nelson P.A. Stothers I.M. Boucher C.C. 1990 “In flight experiments on the active control of propeller induced cabin noise,” Journal of Sound and Vibration 140 219 238
- Elliot S.J. Nelson P.A. Stothers I.M. Boucher C.C. 1989 “Preliminary results of inflight experiments on the active control of propeller-induced cabin noise,” Journal of Sound and Vibration 128 355 357
- Elliot S.J. Strothers I.M. Nelson P.A. 1987(a) “A Multiple Error LMS Algorithm and Its Application to the Active Control of Sound and Vibration,” IEEE Transaction on Acoustic Speech and Signal Processing 1 1423 1434
- Elliot S.J. Curtis A.R.D. Bullmore A.J. Nelson P.A. 1987(b) “The active minimization of harmonic enclosed sound fields. Part III: Experimental verification,” Journal of Sound and Vibration 117 35 58
- Elliot S.J. Nelson P.A. 1985 “The active minimization of sound,” Proceedings of Inter-Noise ‘85 583 586
- Eriksson L.J. Allie M.C. Hoops R.H. Warner J.V. 1989 “Higher order mode cancellation in ducts using active noise control,” Proceedings of Inter-Noise ‘89 1 495 500
- Eriksson L.J. Allie M.C. Bremigan C.D. Gilbert J.A. 1988 “Active noise control and specifications for fan noise problems,” Proceedings of NOISE-CON 88 Purdue University 273 288
- Eriksson L.J. Allie M.C. 1988 “A practical system for active attenuation in ducts,” Sound & Vibration 30 34
- Fahy F. 1985 Sound and Structural Vibration Academic Press Orlando Florida 60 72
- Fanson J.L. Chen J.C. 1986 “Structural Control by the Use of Piezoelectric Active Members,” Proceedings of NASA/DOD Control-Structures Interaction Conference
- Fanson J.L. Blackwood G.H. Chu C.C. 1989 “ACTIVE-member control of precision structures,” Proceedings, 30th SDM Conference Mobile, AL 1480 1494
- Flemming M.R. 1990 “An Experimental Investigation of the Harmonic Excitation of Simply Supported Plates with Multiple Surface-Bonded Piezoceramic Actuators,” Master of Science Thesis in Mechanical Engineering VPI&SU.
- Fuller C.R. 1989 “Active Control of Sound Transmission/Radiation from Elastic Plates by Vibration Inputs: I Analysis,” Journal of Sound and Vibration 1 13
- Fuller C.R. Hansen C.H. Snyder S.D. 1989(a) “Active Control of Structurally Radiated Noise Using Piezoceramic Actuators,” Inter-Noise 89 509 511
- Fuller C.R. Rogers C.A. Robertshaw H.H. 1989(b) “Active Control with Smart Structures,” Fiber Optic Smart Structures and Skins II Udd Eric SPIE 1170 338 358
- Fuller C.R. Gibbs G.P. Silcox R.J. 1990 “Simultaneous Active Control of Flexural and Extensional Waves in Beams,” Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures 1 2 235 247
- Fuller C.R. Burdisso R.A. 1991 “A Wave Number Domain Approach to the Active Control of Structure-Borne Sound,” Journal of Sound and Vibration 148 2 335 360
- Fuller C.R. Hansen C.H. Snyder S.D. 1991 “Active Control of Sound Radiation from a Vibrating Rectangular Panel by Sound Sources and Vibration Inputs: An Experimental Comparison,” Journal of Sound and Vibration 145 2 195 215
- Fuller C.R. Silcox R.J. 1992 “Active Structural Acoustic Control,” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 1991 91 1
- Fuller C.R. Snyder S.D. Hansen C.H. Silcox R.J. 1992 “Active control of interior noise in model aircraft fuselages using piezoceramic actuators,” AIAA Journal 30 11 2613 1617
- Gibbs G.P. Fuller C.R. 1991 “Excitation of thin beams using asymmetric piezoelectric actuators,” The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Gibbs G.P. Fuller C.R. 1992 “Experiments on active control of power flow using piezoceramic actuators and snesors,” AIAA Paper 90-1132 AIAA Journal
- Guicking D. Karcher K. 1984 “Active impedance control for one-dimensional sound,” ASME Journal of Vibration, Acoustics, Stress and Reliability in Design 106 393 396
- Guicking D. Karcher K. Rollwage M. 1985 “Coherent active methods for applications in room acoustics,” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 78 1426 1434
- Hagood N.W. Crawley E.F. 1989 “Experimental investigation into passive damping enhancement for space structures,” AIAA 89-3436 Guidance Navigation and Control Conference boston, MA
- Hanagud S. Obal M.W. Calise A.J. 1986 “Optimal vibration control by the use of piezoceramic sensors and actuators,” Proceedings, 27th SDM Conference San Antonio, TX
- Jaffe B. Roth R.S. Marzullo S. 1954 “Piezoelectric Properties of Lead Zirconate-Lead Titanate Solid-Solution Ceramics,” J. Appl. Phys. 25 6 809 810
- Jaffe B. Cook W.R. Jaffe H. 1971 Piezoelectric Ceramics, Vol. 3 of Non-Metallic Solids Roberts J.P. Popper P. Academic Press Inc. London
- Junger M.C. Feit D. 1986 Sound, Structures, and Their Interaction The MIT Press Second
- Kawai H. 1969 “The Piezoelectricity of Poly(vinylidene Fluoride),” Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 6 7 975 976
- Kwakernaak H. Sivan R. 1972 Linear Optimal Control Systems John Wiley and Sons, Inc. New York, NY
- KYNAR Piezo Film Technical Manual 1987 Pennwalt Corp. Valley Forge, PA
- Lee C.K. Chiang W.W. O'Sullivan T.C. 1989 “Piezoelectric Modal Sensors and Actuators Achieving Critical Damping on a Cantilever Plate,” AIAA Paper , No. 89-1390
- Lee C.K. 1990 “Theory of Laminated Piezoelectric Plates for the Design of Distributed Sensors/Actuators: Part I. Governing Equations and Reciprocal Relationships,” The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 87 1144 1158
- Lee C.K. Moon F.C. 1990 “Modal Sensors/Actuators,” ASME JAM 57 434 441
- Lee C.K. Chiang W.W. O'Sullivan T.C. 1991 “Piezoelectric Modal Sensor/Actuator Pairs for Critical Damping Vibration Control,” The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 90 1 374 384
- Lee C.K. O'Sullivan T.C. 1991 “Piezoelectric Strain Rate Gages,” The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 90 2 945 953
- Lester H.C. Lefebvre Sylvie 1991 “Piezoelectric actuator models for active sound and vibration control of cylinders,” Recent Advances in Active Control of Sound and Vibration Rogers C.A. Fuller C.R. Technomic Publishing Company, Inc. Lancaster PA 3 26
- Lueg P. 1936 Process of silencing sound oscillations US Patent No. 2,043,416
- Maidanik G. 1974 “Vibrational and Radiative Classification of Modes of a Baffled Finite Panel,” The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 34 4 447 455
- Meirovitch L. 1967 Analytical Methods in Vibrations Macmillan Publishing Co. New York, New York
- Metcalf V.L. Fuller C.R. Silcox R.J. Brown D.E. 1992 “Active control of sound transmission/radiation from elastic plates by vibration inputs, II: experiments,” Journal of Sound and Vibration 153 3 387 402
- Miller D.W. Hubbard J.E. 1987 “Observability of a Bernoulli-Euler Beam Using PVFi as a Distributed Sensors,” Dynamics and Control of Large Structures: Proceedings of the 6th VPI&SU/AIAA Symposium Meirovitch L. 375 390
- Miller D.W. Collins S.A. Peltzman S.P. 1990 “Development of Spatially Convolving Sensors for Structural Control Applications,” AIAA Paper , 90-1127-CP 2283 2297
- Miura K. Furuya H. 1988 “Adaptive structure concept for future space applications,” AIAA Journal 26 8
- Naghshineh K. Koopmann G.H. 1993(a) “A design method for achieving weak radiator structures using active vibration control,” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Naghshineh K. Koopmann G.H. 1993(b) “A control strategy for achieving weak radiator structures,” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
- Nelson P.A. Hammond J.K Joseph P. Elliot S.J. 1990 “Active control of stationary random sound fields,” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 87 963 975
- Nelson P.A. Hammond J.K Elliot S.J. 1988 “Analytical approaches to the active control of stationary random enclosed sound fields,” Proceedings of Inter-Noise ‘88 Avignon 2 959 962
- Nelson P.A. Curtis A.R.D. Elliot S.J. Bullmore A.J. 1987 “The active minimization of harmonic enclosed sound fields, Part I: Theory,” Journal of Sound and Vibration 117
- Pan J. Snyder S.D. Hansen C.H. Fuller C.R. 1992 “Active control of far-field sound radiated by a rectangular panel - a general analysis,” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 91 2056 2066
- Piezo Systems 1987 Piezoelectric Motor/Actuator Kit Manual Piezoelectric Products Inc. Cambridge, Maryland
- Plump J.M. Hubbard J.E. Bailey T. 1987 “Nonlinear Control of a Distributed System: Simulation and Experimental Results,” Journal of Dynamic Systems, Measurement and Control 109 133 139
- Rogers C.A. Chen L. Jia J. 1989(a) “Behavior of shape memory alloy reinforced composite plates, part 1: model formulations and control concepts,” Proceedings of the 30th Structure, Structural Dynamics and Materials Conference Mobile, AI AIAA paper 89-1389
- Rogers C.A. Liang C. Jia J. 1989(b) “Behavior of shape memory alloy reinforced composite plates, part 2: results,” Proceedings of the 30th Structure, Structural Dynamics and Materials Conference Mobile, AI AIAA paper 89-1331
- Saunders W.R. Robertshaw H.H. Rogers C.A. 1991 “Structural acoustic control of a shape memory alloy composite beam,” Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures 2 4 508 520
- Saunders W.R. Cole D.G. Robertshaw H.H. 1993 “The impact of sensoriactuators on active structural acoustic control” Proceedings of the SPIE Conference on Smart Structures and Materials Albuquerque, NM 1993
- Saunders W.R. Robertshaw H.H. Burdisso R.A. 1993 “An evaluation of feedback, adaptive feedforward and hybrid controller designs for active structural control of a lightly-damped structure,” Proceedings of the 2nd Conference on Recent Advances in Active Control of Sound and Vibration Blacksburg, VA 1993
- Siever L. von Flotow A. 1990 “Comparison and extensions of control methods for narrowband disturbance rejection,” Proceedings of the 1990 ASME Winter Annual Meeting Dallas, TX Nov. 1990
- Silcox R.J. Lester H.C. Abler S.B. 1990 “An evaluation of active noise control in a cylindrical shell,” ASME Journal of Vibration, Acoustics, Stress and Reliability in Design 112 1
- Silcox R.J. Fuller C.R. Lester H.C. 1990 “Mechanisms of active control in cylindrical fuelage structures,” AIAA Journal 28 8 1397 1404
- Smith P.W. 1962 “Coupling of Sound and Panel Vibration below the Critical Frequency,” The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 36 8 1516 1520
- Snyder S.D. Clark R.L. Hansen C.H. 1991 “Convergence characteristics of the multiple-input, multiple-output LMS algorithm,” Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures 3 1 115 133
- Snyder S.D. Hansen C.H. 1991 “Mechanisms of active noise control using vibration sources,” Journal of Sound and Vibration 147 519 525
- Sommerfeldt S.D. 1991 “Multi-channel adaptive control of structural vibration,” Noise Control Engineering Journal 37 2 88 89
- Sommerfeldt S.D. Scott Brian L. 1993 “Wavenumber sensors for active control of acoustic radiation,” Proceedings of the 1993 North American Conference on Smart Structures and Materials
- Sornmerfeldt S.D. 1993 “Active wavenumber control of acoustic radiation from a plate,” Proceedings of the Second Conference on Recent Advances in Active Control of Sound and Vibration
- Song L. Koopmann G.H. Fahnline J. 1991 “Active control of the acoustic radiation of a vibrating structure using a superposition formulation,” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 89 6
- Stengel R.F. 1986 Adaptive Signal Processing John Wiley and Sons New York
- Swigert C.J. Forward R.L. 1981 “Electronic Damping of Orthognal Bending Modes in a Cylindrical Mast - Part I: Theory, Part II: Experiment,” Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets 18 1 5 17
- Vipperman J.S. Burdisso R.A. Fuller C.R. 1991 “Active Control of Broadband Structural Vibration Using the LMS Adaptive Algorithm,” Journal of Sound and Vibration
- Wada Y. Hayakawa R. 1976 “Piezoelectricity and Pyroelectricity of Polymers,” Jpn J. AppL Phys. 15 11 2041 2057
- Wada Y. Fanson J.L. Crawley E.F. 1990 “Adaptive structures,” Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures 1 2 157 174
- Wallace C.E. 1972 “Radiation Resistance of a Rectangular Panel,” The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 51 3 946 952
- Wang B.T. Burdisso R.A. Fuller C.R. 1991(a) “Optimal Placement of Piezoelectric Actuators for Active Control of Sound Radiation from Elastic Plates,” Proceedings of Noise-Con 91 267 275
- Wang B.T. Dimitriadis E.K. Fuller C.R. 1991(b) “Active Control of Structurally Radiated Noise Using Multiple Piezoelectric Actuators,” AIAA Journal 29 11 1802 1809
- Widrow B. Stearns S.D. 1985 Adaptive Signal Processing Prentice Hall Inc. Englewood Cliffs, NJ