This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Analysis of Human Test Subject Kinematic Responses to Low Velocity Rear End Impacts
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
The head, neck and trunk kinematic responses of four volunteer test subjects, recorded during a series of experimental low velocity motor vehicle collisions, have been measured and analyzed. Using data obtained from multiple high speed film, video and electronic accelerometer measurements of the test subjects, it was found that the actual kinematic responses of the human head, neck and trunk that occur during low velocity rearend collisions are more complex than previously thought. Our findings indicate that the time-honored description of the cervical “whiplash” response is both incomplete and inaccurate.
Although the classic “whiplash” neck response to rearend collisions and the widely accepted hyperextension/hyperflexion cervical injury mechanism have been extensively written and speculated about, there have been little human experimental data available, especially for low velocity collisions. Low velocity collisions are defined in this report as motor vehicle collisions in which the impact related change of the rearended vehicle's velocity (AV) is about 12.9 kph (8 mph) or less. Throughout nearly 4 decades of experimental crash testing, low velocity mishaps (as defined above) have been felt to have a minor injury causation potential and have remained a relatively unstudied area. The absence of good experimental data, accurately defining real occupant kinematic response during this common type of traffic accident has spawned a plethora of divergent concepts, ideas and speculation about possible injury mechanisms.
In February 1991, a series of vehicle collision tests using fully instrumented volunteer human test subject/drivers and a Hybrid III manikin passenger was conducted, utilizing local testing facilities. This project was undertaken to better define human, dummy and vehicle responses during low velocity collisions.
Recommended Content
Authors
- Whitman E. McConnell - Biodynamic Research Corp.
- Richard P. Howard - Biodynamic Research Corp.
- Herbert M. Guzman - Biodynamic Research Corp.
- John B. Bomar - Biodynamic Research Corp.
- James H. Raddin - Biodynamic Research Corp.
- James V. Benedict - Biodynamic Research Corp.
- Harry L. Smith - Biodynamic Research Corp.
- Charles P. Hatsell - Biodynamic Research Corp.
Topic
Citation
McConnell, W., Howard, R., Guzman, H., Bomar, J. et al., "Analysis of Human Test Subject Kinematic Responses to Low Velocity Rear End Impacts," SAE Technical Paper 930889, 1993, https://doi.org/10.4271/930889.Also In
References
- Arthur Ameis Cervical Whiplash: Considerations in the Rehabilitation of Cervical Myofascial Injury. Can. Fam. Physician 32 1871 1876 September 1986
- Balk John I. The Late Whiplash Syndrome Aust. Surg N.Z. J. 50 6 610 614 December 1980
- Berton R.J. Whiplash: Test of the Influential Variables Society of Automotive Engineers 1 10 January 1968
- Big Harvey E. Jr., M.D, F.I.S.C. The Mechanism of Whiplash Injuries International Record of Medicine 169 3 7 1956
- Bogduk Nikolai Ph.D., Dip, Anat. The anatomy and pathophysiology of whiplash Clinical Biomech 1 2 92 101 1986
- Gerd Carlsson Stefan Nilsson Anna Nilsson-Ehle Hans Norin Lars Ysander Roland Ortengren Neck Injuries in Rear End Car Collisions. BioMechanical Considerations to Improve Head Restraints American Association for Automotive Medicine, The Quarterly/Journal 25-30 July 1985
- Clemens H.J. Burow K. Experimental investigation on injury mechanisms of cervical spine at frontal and rear-front vehicle inpacts Proceedings of the Sixteenth Stapp Car Crash Conference 1972 76 104
- Crow H.E. Injuries to the Cervical Spine Paper presented at the Meeting of the Western Orthopaedic Association San Francisco 1928
- Frankel V.H. Tempero mandibular joint pain syndrome following deceleration injury to the cervical spine Bull Hosp. Joint Dis 1965 26 47 51
- Gay James R. M.D. Abbott Kenneth H. MD. Common Whiplash Injuries of the Neck JAMA 152 18 1698 1704 August 29 1953
- Gotten Nicholas MD. Survey of One Hundred Cases of Whiplash Injury After Settlement of Litigation. JAMA 162 9 865 7 October 1956
- Harris W.H. Hamblen D.L. Ojemann R.G. Traumatic disruption of cervical intervertebral disc from hyperextension injury Clin. Orthop. 60 163 167 1968
- Hirsch Stuart A M.D. Hirsch Paul J. M.D. Hiramoto Harlan M.D. Andrew Weiss M.D. Whiplash Syndrome Fact or Fin? Orthopedic Clinics of North America 19 4 791 5 October 1988
- Hohl M Soft-tissue injuries of the neck in automobile accidents J. Bone Joint Surg. 56A 1675 1682 1974
- Howard Richard P. M.D., M.S. Benedict James V. Ph.D., MD Raddin James H. Jr. M.D., S.M. Smith Harry L. Ph.d, MD. Assessing Neck Extension/Flexion as a Basis for Temporomandibular Joint Dysfunction J Oral Maxillofac Surg 49 1210 1213 1991
- Kallieris D. Mattern R., M i, E. Schmidt Gg. Stein K. Considerations for a Neck Injury Criterion University of Heidelberg 401 417 1991
- Henry La Rocca MD. Acceleration Injuries of the Neck Clinical Neurosurgery 25 209 17 1978
- McKenzie J.A. Williams J.F. The Dynamic Behavior of the Head and Cervical Spine During ‘Whiplash’ J. Biomechanics 4 477 490 1971
- Macnab I. Acceleration-extension injuries of the cervical spine. American Academy of Orthopaedic-Surgeons Symposium on the Spine St, Louis; Mosby 1969 10 17
- Macnab I. The whiplash syndrome Clin. Neurosurg 1973 20 232 41
- Ian Macnab M.B, Ch.B., F.R.C.S. The “Whiplash Syndrome” Orthopedic Clinics of Noah America 2 2 389 403 July 1971
- Ian Macnab M.B., Ch.B., F.R.C.S. Acceleration Injuries of the Cervical Spine The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgeries 46-A 8 1797 1799 December 1964
- Martinez J.L. Garcia D.J. A model for whiplash J. Biomech 1968 1 23 32
- Mertz H.J. Patrick L.M. “Investigation of the Kinematics and Kinetics of Whiplash” Proceedings of the 11th Stapp Car Crash Conference 175 206 670919 1967
- Mertz H.J. Patrick L.M Strength and Response of the Human Neck Proceedings of the 15th Stapp Conference 207 255 SAE Paper 710855 1971
- Mertz H.J. “Neck Injury in Biomechanics and its Application to Automotive Design” SAE, Warrendale, Publication No. P. 49 January 1973
- Muzzy III WH Seemann MR Willems GC Lustick LS Bittner AC The Effect of Mass Distribution Parameters on Head/Neck Dynamic Response Proc. 30th Stapp Car Crash Conf. Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 167 184 1986
- Norris S.H. Watt I. “The Prognosis of Neck Injuries Resulting from Rear-end Vehicle Collisions” Journal of Bane and Joint Surgery 65-B 5 608 11 November 1983
- O'Neill B. et. al. “Automobile Head Restraints - Frequency of Neck Injury Claims in Relation to the Presence of Head Restraints” A.J.P.H. 399 406 March 1972
- Pearce J.MS. Whiplash injury: a reappraisal Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry 52 1329 1331 1989
- Pietrobono R. The anatomy of the cervical region with particular reference to the symptomatology of the ‘whiplash’ lesion J. Bone Joint Surg. 1956 38A 438
- Pintar FA Sances A Yoganandan N Reinartz J Maiman DJ Suh JK Unger G Cusick JF Larson SJ Biodynamics of the Total Human Cadaveric Cervical Spine Proc, 34th Stapp Car Crash Conf. Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 55 72 1990
- Prasad P. et. al. “Dynamic Response of the Spine During -GX Acceleration” Proceedings of the 19th Stapp Conference 869 897 SAE Paper No. 751172
- Raney A.A. Raney R.B. Hunter C.R. Chronic posttraumatic headache and the syndrome of cervical disc lesion following head trauma J. Neurosurg. 6 458 465 1949
- Sauces Jr. et al. “Experimental Studies of Brain and Neck Injury” Proceedings of the 25th Stapp Conference 149 194 SAE Paper No. 811032 1981
- Sances Jr. et.al. “Pathophysiology of Cervical Injuries” Proceedings of the 26th Stapp Conference 41 70 SAE Paper No. 821153 1982
- Severy D.M. Mathewson J.H. Bechtol C.O. M.D. Controlled Automobile Rear-End Collisions, an Investigation of Related Engineering and Medical Phenomena Canadian Services Medical Journal VII 727 59 1955
- Snyder R.G. “Human Impact Tolerance” 1970 International Automobile Safety Conference Compendium 712 782 Warrendale Paper No. 700398 1970
- States J.D. Kom M.W. Masengill J.B. “The Enigma of Whiplash Injuries” Proceedings of the 13th Conference of the American Association for Automotive Medicine 83 108 AAAM Arlington Heights, Illinois October 1969
- States J.D. et, al. “Injury Frequency and Head Restraint Effectiveness in Rear-End Impact Accidents” Proceedings of the 16th Stapp Car Crash Conference 228 257 Warrendale Paper No. 720967 November 1972
- Thibault L. Gennarelli T.A. Biomechanics of Diffuse Brain Injuries Proceedings of the 10th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles Oxford, England July 1-4 1985 Washington, DC U.S. Department of Transportation, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration DOT-HS-807-481 March 1989
- Thiemeyer John S. Jr., M.D Duncan. George A. M.D. Hollins George G. Jr., MD. Whip-Lash Injuries of the Cervical Spine Virginia Medical Monthly 85 171 4 April 1958
- Webb Michael N Terrett Allan GJ. Whiplash: Mechanisms and Patterns of Tissue Injury Journal of the Australian Chiropractor's Association 15 2 60 69 June 1985
- Weinberg Simon, DDS FRCD(C) LaPointe Henry, DDS Cervical Extension/Flexion Injury (Whiplash) and Internal Derangement of the Temporomandibular Joint J Oral Maxillofac. Surg 45 653 656 August 1987
- Write A.A. III Panjabi M.M “Clinical Biomechanics of the Spine” Lippincott, philadelphia 1978
- Williams J.F. McKenzie J.A. Technical Notes. ‘The Effect of Collision Severity on the Motion of the Head and Neck During Whiplash’ J. Biomechanics 8 257 259 1975
- Wismans J. Oorschot H. Woltring HJ Omni-Directional Human Head-Neck Response Proc, 30th Stapp Car Crash Conf. Society of Automotive Engineers Warrendale, PA 313 325 1