This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Comparison of Nickel-Hydrogen and Nickel-Cadmium Reliability for Low-Earth-Orbit Batteries
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Nickel-Hydrogen (NiH2) realtime and accelerated low-earth-orbit (LEO) cycle test data at 10°C have been used to generate a model of reliability as a function of depth-of-discharge (DOD). The reliability model is specific to cells incorporating positive electrodes manufactured by the wet slurry process. A cycle life prediction has also been derived from the reliability equation and has been compared to two other predictions: one for NiH2 cells of generic design and one for Nickel-Cadmium (NiCd) hardware. The comparison clearly shows the superiority of NiH2 in LEO.
At each DOD for which test data existed in the 5°C to 10°C range, the realtime and accelerated LEO life cycle test data were algebraically fit to a Weibull distribution which passes through the current cycle count of the ongoing tests, none of which have experienced a failure. The analysis was performed for the 15%, 30% and 40% DOD test conditions for “wet slurry” NiH2. A best-fit to a Weibull distribution was performed for the comparison predictions, at DOD's of 40%, 60% and 80% for “generic” NiH2, and at DOD's from 15% to 50% for NiCd.
The end result of the cell reliability analysis is a plot of cell probability of success (PS) versus cycle time. The PS graph may be converted to a graph of expected cycle life for the case of a battery, given number of cells per battery and a value for required battery reliability. Low earth orbit life test data at 10°C shows that NiH2 has a superior cycle life to the established NiCd system. In addition, the life projections for “wet slurry” NiH2 are above those of “generic” NiH2. In conjunction with the energy density advantage, NiH2 is clearly the system of choice for both GEO and LEO missions requiring high reliability and longer life.
Authors
Topic
Citation
Hafen, D., "Comparison of Nickel-Hydrogen and Nickel-Cadmium Reliability for Low-Earth-Orbit Batteries," SAE Technical Paper 929257, 1992, https://doi.org/10.4271/929257.Also In
References
- Hafen Douglas “Comparison of Nickel-Hydrogen and Nickel-Cadmium Reliability,” Proceedings of the 26th IECEC Boston, MA August 1991
- Byers Gerald W. “Nickel-Hydrogen Low Earth Orbit Testing at Martin Marietta Space Systems,” Proceedings of the 25th IECEC Reno, NV August 1990 6 65 6 68
- McDermott J.K. “Low-Earth-Orbit Testing of Nickel-Hydrogen Cells,” Proceedings of the 21st IECEC San Diego, CA August 1986 1516 1520
- Schiffer Stephen F. Maurer Dorian M. Markowitz Cara A. “NiH 2 Battery Cell Life Tests for Low Earth Orbit Applications,” Proceedings of the 25th IECEC Reno, NV August 1990 3 55 3 60
- Hudak R. E. “Life Test Results of the Intelsat-V Nickel-Hydrogen Battery,” Proceedings of the 22nd IECEC Philadelphia, PA August 1987 897 899
- Armantrout Jon D. Hafen Douglas P. Hudak Ronald E. 23 August 1990
- Coates Dwaine E. Barnett Russell M. “Nickel-Hydrogen Cell Life Testing,” Proceedings of the 23rd lntersociety Energy Conversion Engineering Conference Denver, CO August 1988 2.483 2.488
- Hafen Douglas P. Brill Jack 4 September 1990
- Hafen Douglas P. Brill Jack 30 November 1990
- Hafen Douglas P. Brill Jack 8 February 1991
- Hafen Douglas P. Brill Jack 21 October 1991
- Hall S.W. “Evaluation Program For Secondary Spacecraft Cells, Twenty-Second Annual Report of Cycle Life Test,” Department of the Navy, Naval Weapons Support Center, Weapons Quality Engineering Center Crane, Indiana Report WQEC/C 86-177 9 April 1986
- Hendel B. Dudley G. “Low Earth Orbit Nickel Cadmium Battery Lifetime Testing,” Proceedings of the European Space Power Conference Madrid, Spain 2-6 October 1989 August 1989
- Hendel B. Dudley G. Gave G. “Update on Low-Earth Orbit Nickel Cadmium Battery Lifetime Testing,” Proceedings of the European Space Power Conference Florence, Italy 2-6 September 1991 August 1991
- SAFT Space Department “NiCd Cells, ELAN Program, Low Earth Orbit Cycling,” August 1991
- Nelson Wayne “Hazard Plotting for Incomplete Failure Data,” Journal of Quality Technology 1 1 January 1969 27 52