This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Unanticipated Benefits of Automotive Emission Control: Reduction in Fatalities by Motor Vehicle Exhaust Gas
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
In 1970, before the implementation of strict controls on emissions in motor vehicle exhaust gas (MVEG), the annual U.S. incidence of fatal accidents by carbon monoxide in the MVEG was ∼800 and that of suicides ∼2000 (somewhat less than 10% of total suicides). In 1987, there were ∼400 fatal accidents and ∼2700 suicides by MVEG. Accounting for the growth in population and vehicle registration, the yearly lives saved in accidents by MVEG were ∼1200 in 1987 and avoided suicides ∼1400. The decrease in accidents continues unabated while the decrease in expected suicides by MVEG reached a plateau in 1981-1983. The reasons for this disparity are discussed. Juxtaposition of these results with the projected, but statistically undetectable, cancer risk avoidance of less than 500 annually in 2005 (as compared to 1986) associated with the abatement of ambient MVEG pollutants, plainly shows that, in terms of mortality, the unanticipated benefits of emission control far overshadow the intended benefits. With the spread of MVEG controls these benefits will accrue worldwide.
Authors
Citation
Shelef, M., "Unanticipated Benefits of Automotive Emission Control: Reduction in Fatalities by Motor Vehicle Exhaust Gas," SAE Technical Paper 922335, 1992, https://doi.org/10.4271/922335.Also In
References
- Watson A. Y. Bates R. R. Kennedy D. “Air Pollution, The Automobile and Public Health” National Academy Press Washington, D.C. 1988
- “Air Quality Criteria for Carbon Monoxide” EPA/600/8-10/048 A 1990
- Haldane J. J. Physiol. London 18 1895 430 Douglas C. G. Haldane J. S. Haldane J. B. S. J. Physiol. London 44 1912 275
- Coburn R.F. Forster R. E. Kane P. B. J. Clin. Invest. 44 1965 1899
- Stewart R. D. Ann. Rev. of Pharmac. 15 1975 409
- Kirkpatrick J. N. West. J. of Medicine 146 1987 52
- Broome J. R. Skrike H. Pearson R. R. Br. J. Hosp. Med. 39 1988 298
- Meredith T. Vale A. Brit. Med. J. 296 1988 77
- McBay A. J. N. Eng. J. Med. 272 1965 252
- Stone R. “Introduction to Internal Combustion Engines” Macmillan, London 1985
- Landers D. West. J. of Med. 135 1981 360
- “Users Guide to Mobile-4 (Mobile Source Emission Factor Model) U.S. EPA, Office of Mobile Sources EPA-AA-TEB-89-01 Feb. 1989
- “National Air Pollutant Emission Estimates” U.S. EPA Air, EPA-450/4-90-001 March 1990
- Kummer J. T. Prog. Energy Combust. 6 1980 177
- Hays P. Bornstein R. A. Am. J. Psychiatry 141 1984 592
- Kern R. A. Knoedler J. A. Trester R. J. “Automotive Carbon Monoxide Emissions in a Closed Garage” Soc. Aut. Eng. Paper No 900499 1990
- Hanley R. “Van Fumes Asphyxiate Family of Five in New Jersey” N.Y. Times March 9 1991
- “Vital Statistics of the U.S.” Vol. II-Mortality (Part 1). U.S. Department of HEW National Center for Health Statistics
- Lester D. Clarke R. V. Accid. Anal. & Prev. 21 1989 191
- Cobb N. Etzel R. A. JAMA 266 1991 659
- Lester D. Abe K. Perceptual and Motor Skills 73 1991 306
- Lester D. Clarke R. V. J. of Epidem. and Comm. Health 41 1987 117
- Kreitman N. Platt S. J. of Epidem. and Comm. Health 38 1984
- “Statistical Abstract of the United States” U.S. Dept. of Commerce, Bureau of the Census 1990
- Carey P. M. “Air Toxics Emissions from Motor Vehicles EPA-AA-TSS-PA-86-5
- Adler J. Carey P. M. “Air Toxics Emissions and Health Risks from Toxic Emissions” 82nd Annual Meeting Air and Waste Management Assn. June 25-30 1989
- Abelson P. H. Science 256 1992 1609
- Lipfert F. W. Malone R. G. Daum M. L. Mendell N. R. Chang C.-C. “A Statistical Study of the Macroepidemiology of Air Pollution and Total Mortality” BNL Report 52122 April 1988
- Krupnick A.J. Portney P.R. Science 252 1991 522
- Hall J. V. Winer A. M. Kleinman M. T. Lurmann F. W. Brajer V. Colome S. D. Science 255 1992 812
- Brimelow P. Spencer L. Forbes July 6 1992 Brookes W. T. National Review October 7 1991