This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Repeated Measures of Mental Performances on Transoceanic Flight Crews
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Commercial airline cockpit crews flying transoceanic routes were tested repeatedly with a battery of cognitive tests implemented on a lap-top microcomputer. Testing was conducted before departure and during the early, middle, and late periods in flight on the outbound leg of four flight pairings.
The same tests were administered on the return leg(s) of each flight pairing but, just prior to final administration of the tests, six minutes of moderate resistance exercise was undertaken by the Captain and one other pilot (either the First or Second Officer). The remaining officer substituted a walk around the aircraft cabin for exercise and served as a control. The same Flight Captain was available for testing on all flights (N = 22), but due to scheduling requirements, the same First and Second Officers were available for 4-8 flights each.
Comparisons were made between the two exercise conditions over all test sessions, but no statistical relationships were found. It appeared that effects were masked by the scatter caused by the individual differences in the various performances of the eight different First and Second Officers who alternated through the four flight segments. However, indicators were present in the data of the Flight Captain which supported the hypothesis that exercise had a positive impact on pilot performance. Because the Flight Captain was followed over all his flight segments for a total of 8 months of testing (and which involved some 65 test cycles), the data were treated as a single subject time-series study. In this analysis, two of the six Automated Performance Test System (APTS) tests (Turnage, Kennedy, Smith, Baltzley, & Lane, 1992) (those representing higher order cognitive skills) were statistically significant (p < .05 for Code Substitution and p < .01 for 4-Choice Reaction Time) when comparisons were made between either “middle” or “late” in hop segments versus after “layover” or after “exercise.”
Pilot testing in the future is planned to broaden our experience using this paradigm and to replicate these findings in additional individuals.
Topic
Citation
Cornell, R., Kennedy, R., and Smith, M., "Repeated Measures of Mental Performances on Transoceanic Flight Crews," SAE Technical Paper 921906, 1992, https://doi.org/10.4271/921906.Also In
Enhanced Situation Awareness Technology for Retrofit and Advanced Cockpit Design
Number: SP-0933; Published: 1992-10-01
Number: SP-0933; Published: 1992-10-01
References
- Box, G. E. P. Jenkins, G. M. 1970 Time series analysis forecasting and control San Francisco Holden-Day
- Carter, R. C. 1981 Physiological and performance measurements: A time-series model Preprints of the 51st Annual Meeting of the Aerospace Medical Association 161 162 Aerospace Medical Association
- Cornell, R. A. 1991 Measurement of pilot performance during transoceanic flight: Relationship of fatigue, nutrition and lifestyle An experimental study conducted for Continental Airlines by the University of Central Florida in cooperation with the Essex Corporation, Orlando Facility, the Lindbergh Fund, Inc. through a research grant made available by Mr. and Mrs. James D. Newton and a travel grant made available by Continental Airlines, Inc. Orlando, FL University of Central Florida and Essex Corporation
- Cornell, R. A. 1991 Impact of pilot performance during transoceanic flight using resistance exercise Paper presented at the 62nd Annual Scientific Meeting of the Aerospace Medical Association Cincinnati, OH
- Cornell, R. A. Gergley, G. R. 1991 April Measurement of pilot fatigue on long duration night flights: First steps in an empirical design Orlando, FL University of Central Florida and Essex Corporation
- Department of Transportation 1991 Federal Aviation Requirements 14CFR Part 91.7 [a] 1 Washington, DC Federal Aviation Administration
- Drew, C. G. 1940 An experimental study in mental fatigue Dearnaley E. J. Warr P. B. 1979 Aircrew stress in wartime operations London Academic Press
- Foushee, H. C. 1986 May Assessing fatigue Airline Pilot 19 Graeber, R. C. 1990 Research on the flight deck - lessons in fatigue Paper presented at the 61st Annual Scientific Meeting of the Aerospace Medical Association New Orleans, LA.
- Graeber, R. C. Foushee, H. C. Gander, P. H. Noga, G. R. 1985 Circadian rhythmicity & fatigue in flight operations Journal of UOEH 7
- Hersen, M. Barlow, D. H. 1976 Single case experimental designs Strategies for studying behavior change New York Pergamon
- Hockey, R. Hamilton, P. 1983 The cognitive patterning of stress states Hockey G. R. J. Stress and human fatigue in human performance 331 362 Chichester, England Wiley
- Kennedy, R. S. May, J. G. Dunlap, W.P. Jones, M. B. Smith, M. G. 1991 An automated task load indexing system Final Rep. No. N62269-90-C-0279 Warminster, PA Naval Air Development Center
- Lane, N. E. 1987 Skill acquisition rates and patterns Issues and training implications New York Springer-Verlag
- Naval Aerospace Medican Institute (NAMI) 1991 U. S. Naval Surgeon's Manual (3rd ed.) Washington, DC U.S. Government Printing Office
- Newell, A. Rosenbloom, P. S. 1981 Mechanisms of skill acquisition and the law of practice Hillsdale, NJ Erlbaum
- Siegel, S. 1956 Nonparametric statistics for the behavioral sciences New York McGraw-Hill
- Sloan, S. Cooper, C. 1986 Pilots under stress London Routledge & Kegan Paul
- Turnage, J. J. Kennedy, R. S. Smith, M. G. Baltzley, D. R. Lane, N. E. 1992 Development of microcomputer-based mental acuity tests Ergonomics