This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Summary of the Fire Safety Impacts of Methanol as a Transportation Fuel
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Event:
Government/Industry Meeting
Language:
English
Abstract
Both for air quality and energy security reasons, a great deal of attention is currently being given to methanol as a candidate to complement petroleum to meet future transportation fuel needs. It is important that safety considerations also be taken into account when analyzing the appropriateness of alternative fuels such as methanol for use in the transportation sector. The current fire safety risk with gasoline is substantial: 216,000 fires resulting in 1,000 fatalities, 7,600 serious injuries, and $430 million in property damage. Due to the lower volatility and higher flammable limit of methanol, pure methanol (M100) is projected to result in as much as a 90 percent reduction in the number of automotive fuel related fires relative to gasoline. A smaller but significant reduction of 40 percent is projected for M85, a blend of 85 percent methanol and gasoline. Assuming that concerns over flame luminosity can be solved with a fuel additive, then due to the greatly reduced heat release rate from a fire, as much as a 95 percent reduction in fire related fatalities and injuries relative to gasoline may result with M100. As much as a 70 percent reduction in fatalities and injuries may be possible with M85. In addition to flame luminosity concerns, fuel tank flammability concerns also exist with M100. While a considerable difference of opinion exists on these issues, it is hoped that by implementing certain vehicle modifications and utilizing fuel additives, these concerns can be greatly reduced or eliminated.
Recommended Content
Technical Paper | Design Guidelines for Methanol Refuelling Stations - 1992 |
Technical Paper | Volatility and Flammability of Variable Fuel Vehicle Tank Contents |
Technical Paper | Fleet Testing of Methanol Gasoline Blends in Public Filling Stations |
Authors
Topic
Citation
Machiele, P., "Summary of the Fire Safety Impacts of Methanol as a Transportation Fuel," SAE Technical Paper 901113, 1990, https://doi.org/10.4271/901113.Also In
References
- 1986 National Fire Incident Reporting System (NFIRS) operated by the Federal Emergency Management Administration (FEMA)
- “Summary and Analysis of Comments Regarding the Potential Safety Implications of Onboard Vapor Recovery Systems,” Office of Mobile Sources U.S. EPA August 1988
- “Study of Motor Vehicle Fires,” February 1988
- Fatal Accident Reporting System NHTSA, DOT, 1980-4
- “Evaluation of Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard 301-75, Fuel System Integrity: Passenger Cars,” DOT HS-806-335 January 1983
- “Draft MOBILE4 Fuel Consumption Model,” EPA/OAR/OMS/ECTD 1989
- “A Perspective on the Flammability, Toxicity, and Environmental Safety Distinctions Between Methanol and Conventional Fuels,” Machiele Paul A. U.S. EPA Paper No. 43b presented at the American Institute of Chemical Engineers 1989 Summer National Meeting Philadelphia, PA August 22 1989
- MVMA Gasoline Fuel Survey Summer Winter 1984
- “A Predictive Study for Defining Limiting Temperatures and Their Application in Petroleum Product Specifications,” Doner John P. Coating and Chemical Laboratory NTIS AD-756420 November 1972
- “Heavy Truck Fuel System Safety Study,” NHTSA DOT HS 807484 September 1989
- “Characterization of Emissions from a Methanol Fueled Motor Vehicle,” Snow Richard et al. JAPCA 39 1 January 1989
- “Assessment of the Safety of Transportation, Distribution and Storage of Methanol Fuels,” R.F. Webb for Transport Canada September 1988
- “Consumer Safety Hazards of Low RVP Motor Gasolines,” Letter to William Reilly, Administrator of EPA from Robinson Richard I., Vice-President of Refining, Phillips 66 Company March 12 1990
- MVMA Diesel Fuel Surveys 1982-1988
- “Further Investigation of the Safety of Methanol Fuels,” Battista Vittoria Transport Canada American Institute of Chemical Engineers 1989 Summer National Meeting Philadelphia, PA August 22 1989
- “Survey of Safety Related Additives for Methanol Fuel,” Fanick E. Robert Smith Lawrence R. Southwest Research Institute for EPA EPA 460/3-84-016 November 1984
- “Investigation into Methanol Fuel Formulations,” Kirshenblatt Morrie Bol Matthew A. Sypher Mueller International Inc. SAE Paper No. 881599