This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Load-Limiters Effect on Occupant Restraint System Performance
Technical Paper
2016-01-1505
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
This paper investigates the role that load-limiters play with respect to the performance of occupant protection systems, with focus on performance in frontal crashes. Modern occupant protection systems consist of not just the seat belt, but also airbags, interior vehicle surfaces and vehicle structure. Modern seat belts very often incorporate load-limiters as well as pretensioners. Published research has established that load-limiters and pretensioners increase the effectiveness of occupant protection systems. Some have argued that load-limiters with higher deployment thresholds are always better than load-limiters with lower deployment thresholds. Through testing, modeling and analysis, we have investigated this hypothesis, and in this paper we present test and modeling data as well as a discussion to this data and engineering mechanics to explain why this hypothesis is incorrect. Research presented in this paper shows that because load-limiters are just one component of a multi-component occupant protection system, the performance of the overall occupant protection system cannot be predicted from the load-limiter performance or specifications alone. The overall occupant protection system is designed such that the load-limiter works in conjunction with the webbing stiffness, airbag, vehicle interior surfaces and vehicle structure to provide effective occupant protection. This paper shows that effective occupant protection has been achieved using different combinations of these parameters. The appropriate method of evaluating the effectiveness of an occupant protection system is to evaluate the overall performance of that occupant protection system in sled and crash tests and/or calibrated modeling. Tests of load-limiters alone or reliance on the load-limiter specification alone is not a good indicator of the overall effectiveness of an occupant protection system. Tests were conducted to establish the level at which certain retractor load-limiters deployed webbing. This data was cross-referenced with publically available test data, and shoulder belt loads, chest deflection and chest compression, among other injury metrics. Computer modeling was conducted to assess the effect of varying initial load-limiter deployment loads.
Recommended Content
Ground Vehicle Standard | Procedure and Instrumentation for Measuring Acoustic Impulses from Deployment of Automotive Inflatable Devices |
Technical Paper | Simulation of Seat Integrated Side Airbag Deployment |
Journal Article | The Front Center Airbag |
Authors
Topic
Citation
Van Arsdell, W., Weber, P., Stankewich, C., Larson, B. et al., "Load-Limiters Effect on Occupant Restraint System Performance," SAE Technical Paper 2016-01-1505, 2016, https://doi.org/10.4271/2016-01-1505.Also In
References
- McElhaney , J. , Roberts , V. , Melvin , J. , Shelton , W. et al. Biomechanics of Seat Belt Design SAE Technical Paper 720972 1972 10.4271/720972
- Begeman , P. and King , A. The Effect of Variable Load Energy Absorbers on the Biodynamic Response of Cadavers SAE Technical Paper 751168 1975 10.4271/751168
- Adomeit , D. Evaluation Methods for the Biomechanical Quality of Restraint Systems During Frontal Impact SAE Technical Paper 770936 1977 10.4271/770936
- Foret-Bruno , J. , Hartemann , F. , Thomas , C. , Fayon , A. et al. Correlation Between Thoracic Lesions and Force Values Measured at the Shoulder of 92 Belted Occupants Involved in Real Accidents SAE Technical Paper 780892 1978 10.4271/780892
- Walsh , M , Kelleher , B. Development and Evaluation of a Belt Restraint System for Small Cars Using Force Limiting DOT HS 805 303 1979
- Dance , M. and Enserink , B. Safety Performance Evaluation of Seat Belt Retractors SAE Technical Paper 790680 1979 10.4271/790680
- 1980 NPRM 209 August 4 1980
- 1981 Modification of FMVSS 209 for Load-limiters. 46 FR 2618
- Claybrook , J. Preamble FMVSS 209 Load-limiters NHTSA Docket 80-12 Jan 12 1981 1981
- Rouhana , S. , Ridella , S. , and Viano , D. The Effect of Limiting Impact Force on Abdominal Injury: A Preliminary Study SAE Technical Paper 861879 1986 10.4271/861879
- 1988 FMVSS 209 FRM. 53 FR 5579
- 1990 NPRM 209 1-18-90. 55 FR 1681
- Mertz , H. , Horsch , J. , Horn , G. , and Lowne , R. Hybrid III Sternal Deflection Associated with Thoracic Injury Severities of Occupants Restrained with Force-Limiting Shoulder Belts SAE Technical Paper 910812 1991 10.4271/910812
- Hill , J. , Mackay , G. , Morris , A. Chest and Abdominal Loading Injuries Caused By Seat Belt Loading AAAM. 1992
- Nilson , G. , Haland , Y. A Force-limiting Device to Reduce the Seat-belt Loading to the Chest and the Abdomen in Frontal Impacts IRCOBI 1993
- 1995213 - FRM - Response to Petitions for Reconsideration. 60 FR 24797
- Miller , H. Injury Reduction with Smart Restraint Systems AAAM. 1995
- Mertz , H. , Williamson , J. , and Vander Lugt , D. The Effect of Limiting Shoulder Belt Load with Air Bag Restraint SAE Technical Paper 950886 1995 10.4271/950886
- Kallieris , D. , Rizzetti , A. , Mattern , R. , Morgan , R. et al. On the Synergism of the Driver Air Bag and the 3-Point Belt in Frontal Collisions SAE Technical Paper 952700 1995 10.4271/952700
- Miller , H. Occupant Performance with Constant Force Restraint Systems SAE Technical Paper 960502 1996 10.4271/960502
- Miller , H. and Maripudi , V. Restraint Force Optimization for a Smart Restraint System SAE Technical Paper 960662 1996 10.4271/960662
- Crandall , J. , Bass , C. , Pilkey , W. , Morgan , R. et al. Thoracic Response and Injury with Belt, Driver Side Air Bag, and Constant Force Retractor Restraints International Journal of Crash worthiness 2 1 1 19 132 1997
- Bendjellal , F. , Walfisch , G. , Steyer , C. , Ventre , P. et al. The Programmed Restraint System - A Lesson from Accidentology SAE Technical Paper 973333 1997 10.4271/973333
- NHTSA Interpretation Letter to Ford March 28, 1998 Load-limiters NHTSA. 1998
- Foret-Bruno , J. , Trosseille , X. , Le Coz , J. , Bendjellal , F. et al. Thoracic Injury Risk in Frontal Car Crashes with Occupant Restrained with Belt Load Limiter SAE Technical Paper 983166 1998 10.4271/983166
- Hinch , J. , Hollowell , W. , Kanianthra , J. , Evans , W. , Klein , T. , Longthorn , A. , Ratchford , S. , Morris , J. , Subramanian , R. Air Bag Technology in Light Passenger Vehicles NHTSA June 27 2001 2001
- Glassman , J. NHTSA Interpretation Letter to Magna Sept 19 2001 - Load-limiters NHTSA 9 19 2001 2001
- Clute , G. Potentials of Adaptive Load Limitation, Presentation and System Validation of the Adaptive Load-limiter ESV 2001-134 2001
- Foret-Bruno , J. , Trosseille , X. , Page , Y. , Huafre , J. , Coz , J. , Bendjellal , F. , Diboine , A. , Phalempin , T. , Villeforceix , D. , Baudrit , P. , Guillemot , H. , Coltat , J. Comparison of Thoracic Injury Risk in Frontal Car Crashes for Occupant Restrained Without Belt Load-limiters and Those Restrained with 6 kN and 4 kN Belt Load-limiters SAE 2001-22-0009 2001
- Sieveka , E. , Kent , R. , Crandall , J. Comparison of Seat Belt Force-limiting Methods Using the MADYMO Multi-body/finite Element Program AAAM 45 11 21 2001
- 2001 FMVSS 209: Petition & Denial for Reconsideration. 66 FR 18208
- Advocates Advocates Response to NHTSA Report on Pretensioner - Loadlimiter [docket - 2003-148308-0003], Advocates 2003
- Alliance Alliance Response to NHTSA Report on Pretensioner - Loadlimiter [docket - 2003-148308-0004], Alliance 2003
- IIHS IIHS Response to NHTSA Report on Pretensioner -Loadlimiter [docket - 2003-148308-0002], IIHS 2003
- Kent , R. , Lessley , D , Shaw , G , Crandall , J. The Utility of Hybrid III and THOR Chest Deflection for Discriminating Between Standard and Force-limiting Belt Systems SAE 2003-22-0013 2003
- Walz , M. NCAP Test Improvements with Pretensioners and Load-limiters NHTSA DOT HS 809 562 2003
- Wang , J. , Zhou , Q. A Seat Belt Buckle Pretensioner and Load-limiter Combo Device ESV 18ESV-000144 2003
- Kahane , C. Lives Saved By the Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards and Other Vehicle Safety Technologies, 1960-2002 NHTSA DOT HS 809 833 2004
- Mertz , H. , Dalmotas , D. Effects of Shoulder Belt Limit Forces on Adult Thoracic Protection in Frontal Collisions SAE 2007-22-0015 2007
- Brumbelow , M. Effects of Seat Belt Load-Limiters on Driver Fatalities in Frontal Crashes of Passenger Cars Panel Presentation at SAE Government & Industry Meeting May 2007
- Brumbelow , M. , Naker , B. , Nolan , J. Effects of Seat Belt Load-limiters on Driver Fatalities in Frontal Crashes of Passenger Cars ESV 07-0067-W 2007
- Kent , R. , Balandin , D. , Bolotnik , N. , Pilkey , W. Optimal Control of Restraint Forces in An Automobile Impact Journal of Dynamic Systems, Measurement, and Control. 2007
- Kent , R. , Forman , J , Parent , D. , Kuppa , S. The Feasibility and Effectiveness of Belt Pretensioning and Load Limiting for Adults in the Rear Seat International Journal of Vehicle Safety 2 4 378 403 2007
- Jenkins , J. , Steffens , C. , and Turvill , W. Forensic Analysis of Seat Belt Retractor Torsion Bars SAE Technical Paper 2009-01-1242 2009 10.4271/2009-01-1242
- Jakstis , M. , Clyde , H. , Hare , B. , Landis , R. et al. Marks on Seat Belt Systems with Pretensioners and Force Limiters in Airbag Deployment Crashes SAE Technical Paper 2009-01-1252 2009 10.4271/2009-01-1252
- Sohr , S. , Heym , A. Benefit of Adaptive Occupant Restraint Systems with Focus on the New US-NCAP Rating Requirements ESV 09-0322 2009
- Bostrom , O. , Mroz , K. , Pipkorn , B. , and Olsson , J. Influence of Belt Load-Limiting Force on Thorax Deflection, Rib Strain and Excursion in Frontal Impacts - A Numerical Evaluation using THUMS and HIII Panel Presentation at Government & Industry Meeting 2009
- Lange , R. , Pearce , H. , Jacuzzi , E. Installation Patterns for Emerging Injury Mitigation Technologies ESV 11-0088-O 2011
- Lu , H. , Andreen , M. , Faust , D. , Furton , L. et al. Safety Belt and Occupant Factors Influencing Thoracic & Upper Abdominal Injuries in Frontal Crashes SAE Technical Paper 2011-01-1129 2011 10.4271/2011-01-1129
- Kahane , C. Injury Vulnerability and Effectiveness of Occupant Protection Technologies for Older Occupants and Women NHTSA DOT HS 811 766 2013
- Kahane , C. Effectiveness of Pretensioners and Load-limiters for Enhancing Fatality Reduction By Seat Belts NHTSA DOT HS 811 835 2013
- Kahane , C. Lives Saved By Vehicle Safety Technologies and Associated Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards, 1960 to 2012 NHTSA DOT HS 812 069 2015