This content is not included in
your SAE MOBILUS subscription, or you are not logged in.
Front and Rear Car Crush Coefficients for Energy Calculations
Technical Paper
2010-01-0069
ISSN: 0148-7191, e-ISSN: 2688-3627
Annotation ability available
Sector:
Language:
English
Abstract
Quantifying the energy associated with vehicle damage is the basis of common methods used to reconstruct car crashes. This study sought to characterize the relationship between crush and energy for the front and rear surfaces of a passenger car. Nine stationary barrier crash tests and one aligned car-to-car test were conducted using several cars of the same model with impact speeds ranging from 4.3 to 15.2 m/s generating as much as 0.47 m of crush. The results revealed a linear speed-crush relationship for front and rear car surfaces and a restitution coefficient that decreased from a maximum of 0.33 at low speed to a relatively constant value of 0.15 for crush levels above 0.2 m. Crush coefficients derived from the crash tests were compared to the coefficients from three other sources: i) default values from the CRASH3 computer program, ii) values from a published database and iii) values derived from an assumed damage threshold value and an NHTSA high-speed crash test. Crush coefficients generated using these methods did not reflect the difference between front and rear stiffness properties indicated by the crash test data. Only calculations using crush coefficients derived directly from the tests and including the effects of restitution accurately predicted the actual barrier impact speeds and speed changes. Based on our results, assuming the same front and rear damage thresholds when calculating crush coefficients may not be appropriate. Considering a range of damage threshold values from 2.2 m/s to 4.5 m/s would have, at least for the car used in this study, provided a range of predicted impact speeds that bracketed the actual values. Ignoring the effects of restitution, or assuming a restitution coefficient of zero, in the derivation and application of crush coefficients will tend to under-estimate the actual speed change.
Recommended Content
Authors
Topic
Citation
Lawrence, J., Fix, R., Ho, A., King, D. et al., "Front and Rear Car Crush Coefficients for Energy Calculations," SAE Technical Paper 2010-01-0069, 2010, https://doi.org/10.4271/2010-01-0069.Also In
References
- Campbell K.L. “Energy Basis for Collision Severity,” SAE Technical Paper 740565 1974
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration “Crash3 User's Guide and Technical Manual” US Department of Transportation, Accident Investigation Division Washington, DC 1979
- Kerkhoff, J.F. Husher, S.E. Varat, M.S. Busenga, A.M. et al. “An Investigation Into Vehicle Frontal Impact Stiffness, BEV and Repeated Testing for Reconstruction,” SAE Technical Paper 930899 1993
- Strother, C.E. Woolley, R.L. Warner, M.B. Warner, C.Y. “Crush Energy in Accident Reconstruction,” SAE Technical Paper 860371 1986
- Woolley, R. Strother, C.E. James, M.B. “Rear Stiffness Coefficients Derived From Barrier Test Data,” SAE Technical Paper 910120 1991
- Varat, M.S. Husher, S.E. Kerkhoff, J.F. “An Analysis of Trends of Vehicle Frontal Impact Stiffness,” SAE Technical Paper 940914 1994
- Prasad A.K. “Crash3 Damage Algorithm Reformulation for Front and Rear Collisions,” SAE Technical Paper 900098 1990
- Neptune, J.A. Blair, G.Y. Flynn, J.E. “A Method for Quantifying Vehicle Crush Stiffness Coefficients,” SAE Technical Paper 920607 1992
- McHenry, R.R. McHenry, B.G. “A Revised Damage Analysis Procedure for the CRASH Computer Program,” SAE Technical Paper 861894 1986
- McHenry, R.R. McHenry, B.G. “Effects of Restitution in the Application of Crush Coefficients,” SAE Technical Paper 970960 1997
- Neptune, J.A. “Crush Stiffness Coefficients, Restitution Constants, and a Revision of CRASH3 & SMAC,” SAE Technical Paper 980029 1998
- King, D.J. Ptucha, S.J. Gardiner, J.M.K. “Speed Change Determination in Low-Speed Impacts-A Comparison of Techniques,” SAE Technical Paper 980023 1998
- Paolini V Travale D Levan W “Final Report of FMVSS Nos. 208, 212, 219 (Partial) and 301 Compliance Testing of a 1992 Chevrolet Cavalier 2-door Coupe,” NHTSA CN0108, CALSPAN Test 7953-2 November 1991
- Jiang T Grzebieta R Rechnitzer G Richardson S Zhao X “Review of Car Frontal Stiffness Equations for Estimating Vehicle Impact Velocities” Proceedings of the 18th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles Nagoya, Japan May 2003
- Smith, R.A. Noga, J.T. “Accuracy and Sensitivity of CRASH,” SAE Technical Paper 821169 1982
- Strother, C.E. Woolley, R.L. James, M.B. “A Comparison Between NHTSA Crash Test data and CRASH3 Frontal Stiffness Coefficients,” SAE Technical Paper 900101 1990
- Neptune, J.A. Flynn, J.E. “A Method for Determining Accident Specific Crush Stiffness Coefficients,” SAE Technical Paper 940913 1994
- Bailey, M.N. Wong, B.C. Lawrence, J.M. “Data and Methods for Estimating the Severity of Minor Impacts,” SAE Technical Paper 950352 1995
- Heinrichs, B.E. Lawrence, J.M. Allin, B.D. Bowler, J.J. et al. “Low-Speed Impact Testing of Pickup Truck Bumpers,” SAE Technical Paper 2001-01-0893 2001
- Emori R “Mechanics of Automobile Collisions” International Conference on Vehicle Mechanics July 1968 Detroit, MI
- Monson, K.L. Germane, G.J. “Determination and Mechanisms of Motor Vehicle Structural Restitution from Crash Tests Data,” SAE Technical Paper 1999-01-0097 1999
- Bailey, M.N. Lawrence, J.M. Fowler, S.J. Williamson, P.B. et al. “Data from Five Staged Car to Car Collisions and Comparison with Simulations,” SAE Technical Paper 2000-01-0849 2000
- Siegmund, G.P. King, D.J. Montgomery, D.T. “Using Barrier Impact Data to Determine Speed Change in Aligned, Low-Speed Vehicle-to-Vehicle Collisions,” SAE Technical Paper 960887 1996
- Siegmund, G.P. Bailey, M.N. King, D.J. “Characteristics of Specific Automobile Bumpers in Low-Velocity Impacts,” SAE Technical Paper 940916 1994
- King, D.J. Siegmund, G.P. Bailey, M.N. “Automobile Bumper Behavior in Low-Speed Impacts,” SAE Technical Paper 930211 1993
- Howard, R.P. Bomar, J. Bare, C. “Vehicle Restitution Response in Low Velocity Collisions,” SAE Technical Paper 931842 1993
- Rose, N.A. Fenton, S.J. Beauchamp, G. “Restitution Modeling for Crush Analysis: Theory and Validation,” SAE Technical Paper 2006-01-0908 2006